2016 Alabama Football Report
It’s time again for another prognostication for the upcoming Alabama football season. Alabama has achieved one of the great dynasties in modern college football history. As winners of four of the last seven national titles, nobody has seen this level of sustained dominance in decades. The Miami Hurricanes (’83, ’87, ’89, & ’91) were the last team to demonstrate so much success. Keep in mind, when Alabama opens 2016 ranked #1, it will constitute the ninth straight year where the Tide has reached the top ranking in nine straight seasons. In the regular season, Alabama has averaged an 11-1 record over the last nine years. Alabama has won three of the last four SEC titles. Alabama is the team of this millennium.
The question: can they do it again this year?
The Caveat
I don’t know anything about the X’s and O’s of football. I just talk and read and collect lots of lots of information. I also do not have time to worry about grammar and typos. Sorry.
Last Year
Pretty stellar. I said I liked Alabama to go 11-1, win the SEC, and beat Baylor for the national title. Pretty right on the money.
Season Comparison
I would compare this season most closely to 2010. That may scare some people. Looking back, the 2010 may have been Saban’s overall most talented group. Alabama had six starters off that defense taken in the 1st round of the NFL draft (with Courtney Upshaw being the first pick of the second round). That team had an elite cadre of skills players and an impressive offensive line. However, that team struggled with apathy following the 2009 national title. The team had lots of players with off the field problems, a sense of entitlement, and several players with their eyes more on the NFL than on winning another national title. Ultimately, that group had Saban’s worst record of the last nine year: 10-3.
In 2016, I think we have a similar situation. Coaches privately have said this is Saban’s most talented Alabama team. Saban subtly in public and more explicitly in private has remarked about a struggle to find good leaders. In the last two years, Saban frequently would talked about how much he liked both the 2014 and 2015 squads. They had strong leadership and good buy in. Saban has not said anything positive yet about liking the feel and leadership of this team. I do not think, however, that this team will go 9-3 in the regular season.
Here’s the difference in my opinion. The 2010 team had a murderous schedule. They played seven opponents with bye weeks before they played Alabama. This year’s schedule is challenging but nothing like 2010. Secondly, Saban and company have dealt with the complacency issues before and know how to handle it better. Finally, the 2010 was not behind it’s quarterback, a central leader on any football team. I get the impression that this year’s eventual starter may be someone the rest of the team will rally behind.
Season in a Nutshell
Alabama will have an historically good defense and compete with the 2011 defense for the title of Saban’s best. Compared to most conservative Alabama offenses, this group will have more upside and downside than normal Saban offenses (which typically seek to limit mistakes at the expense of explosiveness). The Tide will be a dominant team that will make the the playoff through the backdoor.
The Offense
This group may be explosive at times and really struggle at others. I think it will get better as the season progresses and be fun and exciting by the end of the year.
Quarterback
For the third year in a row, a quarterback battle has been the talk of the fall. Out of nowhere, true freshman Jalen Hurts has emerged as an internet legend. I think the legend is true. In both of the scrimmages, Hurts, who was an early entry, has been more successful than any of the quarterbacks at moving the ball and leading drives that end in touchdowns. He has a knack for big plays, both with his feet and through the deep ball, but he also turns the ball over like a true freshman is expected to do. Cooper Bateman, who has been the expected starter as the more experienced player, has not shown the same level of upside as Hurts but has exhibited the same downside. Bateman has thrown multiple interceptions in the scrimmages. Just my opinion, Blake Barnett will never play meaningful snaps and will transfer after this year. He seems to be a player who thrives in 7-on-7, but in real game situations with a pass rush pursuing him, he just doesn’t have it. I could be wrong, but I think Barnett is a non-factor.
I think the QB situation will play out like this. I think the coaches believe Hurts is the best option for the season, and they realize how limited Bateman is. I think they also are afraid to give Hurts too much, too early such that he fails and they damage his confidence (ala Kenny “Trill” Hill and Kyle Allen). I think Bateman will take the first snaps in the first two games, and Hurts will get equal or more snaps throughout those games. I think Hurts will start the Ole Miss game and serve as the primary QB for the remainder of the season. I am buying the hype, and think Hurts will be a star. I think he will be exciting and fun, and will make some really bad decisions during this season.
I should add that I've been totally wrong on the QB situation for two straight years. I thought Sims would be a disaster and Coker would win the job. I thought Bateman would edge out Coker. So your confidence in my opinion should be skeptical at best.
Grade: B with lots of Upside- I could be totally wrong, but I think Hurts will win the job in time and be a very productive player as the season progresses.
Running Back
It is a weird sensation coming into a season at Alabama without a proven, established star running back. I don’t see that star in the stable at this point. Damien Harris seems to be pretty good but not great. Bo Scarborough, who I expected to be a star, does not seem to have won the confidence of the coaches. He has elite athletic talent but does not appear to have emerged as a complete back who can stay healthy. My guess is he will get 6-10 carries per game and will show flashes of greatness, but I personally do not think he is someone who will get 15-20 carries in a game. (Maybe the coaches are just preserving him, knowing that he’s injury prone.) The majority of the early season talk has been around true freshmen B.J. Emmons and Joshua Jacobs, in particular. Jacobs apparently has been the most productive of all the backs.
In this group, I think it will be running back by committee among three players, maybe even four. I don’t expect any star to emerge here but think that the offensive line is good enough that Alabama will have a strong running game.
Grade: B with upside- I think we’ve been spoiled by Coffey, Ingram, Richardson, Lacy, Yeldon, and Henry. Our backs are plenty good, and there are plenty of talented players and our rushing game will be productive because the offensive line is very good.
Receivers
This is an elite unit, perhaps the best we have had at Alabama in my lifetime. Calvin Ridley set the Alabama record for receptions as a freshman and is a preseason first-team All-American. Ardarius Stewart, though he has a penchant for drops, made numerous clutch catches in tight games last year. In re-watching last year, I think we underrate how valuable and productive Stewart is to our team. Robert Foster is also elite, however, I have heard there is concern about how his injury from last year has healed. Grad transfer Gehrig Dieter should be as productive as Richard Mulaney was for Alabama last year. His numbers from Bowling Green were extremely impressive and he is reported to be a better athlete than Mulaney was. Cam Sims has also shown flashes.
Grade: A+ with downside- Numerous publications rate this the top receiver unit in the country. If Foster is not healthy, it could hurt some of the potency of the group.
Tight End
This is surprisingly a great group for Alabama. O.J. Howard is preseason All-SEC. He broke out against Clemson in the national title game. I think his success in the Clemson game will help Howard be more assertive and confident. I also think Kiffin will work to involve Howard in the offense more. Apparently in the preseason scrimmages Howard has caught a lot of passes. Last year, many overlooked the activity of blocking tight end Hale Hentges, who was increasingly effective as the year progressed. Hentges is a reliable blocker and an undervalued player. Brandon Greene has lost a substantial amount of weight and seems poised to have a surprisingly good season for Alabama as a blocker.
Grade: A and steady- I think Howard will have a big season for the Tide. I think we can make too much of the Clemson game where he blew up, largely because he was uncovered. Howard though has always had great upside but has lacked a sense of assertiveness and confidence.
Offensive Line
Alabama recruited offensive line poorly from 2010-2012. As a result, depth and talent were a problem in 2013-14. Mario Cristobal has recruited lights out at OL since coming to Alabama. The Tide is loaded with talent and depth now. With that being said, the Tide also has added Brent Key to serve as the line coach for guards and centers. From what I understand, Cristobal is an elite recruiter and an asset to the staff, but was not the strongest technical offensive line coach. Adding Key to the line I think only will make the group stronger. Cam Robinson is a preseason first team All-American and projected first round pick next year. True freshman Jonah Williams will start at right tackle and is reportedly the next great left tackle for Alabama. Lester Cotton may be my favorite guard prospect of the Saban era. He is an athletic load. I was told that Cotton, who weighs around 320, ran a faster 40yd than all but one player at the NFL Combine among players who weighed 320 or more. I think Cotton will be outstanding. Ross Piersbacher, who was a freshman All-American, has moved from guard to center. I’ve been told that Piersbacher is more of a finesse player than a power blocker, making center a better position for him than guard. There may be some kinks to work out for him as a center but he should do well. The right guard spot has been a fierce competition. It looks as if Bradley Bozeman, a strong and versatile player, will win the job. Fortunately, Alphonse Taylor, Brandon Kennedy, and Dallas Warmack all provide good depth.
Grade: A and steady- Several publications rate this the top offensive line position group in the country. I think the left side of the line will be filthy good with Robinson and Cotton.
Offense Overall Grade: B+ / A- with upside
The offense is a weird situation. You have incredible receivers but the quarterback situation is uncertain. You have a really good offensive line but no discernible feature running back. In the end, I think this will be a balanced and productive offense that will be better overall than the group last year. If Hurts lives up to the hype, look out. We could be in for something special.
Defense
I don’t need to write much here. This is going to be the best defense in the country and will possibly be Saban’s best defense at Alabama. It will rival 2011 in dominance. I listened to a podcast where an insider said that some NFL scouts who have visited Tuscaloosa since the spring have remarked that it’s the fastest and most athletic defense they had seen since Miami 2001. I really do think it may be an “all time” kind of defense.
Defensive Line
This is going to be a great group for the Tide. At defensive end, Jonathan Allen was near the top of the league in sacks last year and will be a first round pick in 2017. Dalvin Tomlinson is quietly a very good contributor. Da’Shawn Hand was the top player in the nation coming out of high school and is poised for a great year. Some think there’s an outside shot that he could have a big year and then jump to the NFL. (I think that’s unlikely but it speaks to how talented he is.) In the middle, Da’Ron Payne is elite. He may be the most important player on the DL. My concern relates to depth in the middle. After Payne, I have not heard anything inspiring (or bad) about O.J. Smith, Dakota Ball, Johnny Dwight, or Josh Frazier (who has the most upside). I worry that against power running teams, depth may hurt us at nose tackle. At the same time, we run a 4-3 pretty often these days, and the lack of depth among true nose tackles may not make a difference. The only newcomer about whom I have heard anything is Raekwon Davis, who appears to be the largest human being ever born. He is 6’7”, 315 pounds and the most imposing freshman I’ve ever seen. There still remain questions about whether he has been cleared academically to compete for Tide.
I think this group will be very good at rushing the passer. I think we should prepare for a bit of a drop off against the run from last year. Keep in mind that Jarran Reed and A’shawn Robinson constituted one of the great run stuffing duos in Alabama football history. The may be more responsible for Derrick Henry winning the Heisman than anyone (see: LSU, Leonard Fournette). In this group, I think Payne and Hand are two emerging stars to watch out for.
DL Grade: A with Downside: An injury to Jonathan Allen or Da’Ron Payne could really hurt this unit. Depth is a concern. The first group, though, is as good as you’ll get in the country.
Linebackers
I’m prone to exaggerate, but this group of linebackers may be my favorite unit ever. College football news has Reuben Foster as a preseason first team All-American and Tim Williams as a second string. Mel Kiper currently has OLD Tim Williams listed as the #2 overall pick for the 2017 draft on his Big Board. He has added some weight and appears set to be more of an every down factor, rather than just a pass rush specialist. From spring scrimmages, a unanimous opinion I’ve heard is that Rashaan Evans has been the most impressive player on the defense. He is an electrifying player who had two sacks in the national title game. On every play, I will have my eyes on #32 (Evans) and #56 (Williams). Meanwhile, the forgotten member of this group, Ryan Anderson, may be the most productive overall player in the group. He had six sacks and 11.5 tackles for loss in 2015. I also have heard that Anfernee Jennings and Christian Miller provide valuable depth and have bright futures.
The exciting development for me is that Evans and Williams have both developed such that these four (Anderson, Evans, Williams, and Foster) likely will be able to stay on the field for all three downs on most occasions. Altogether, I’ve never been more excited about a group of linebackers as an Alabama fan. The pass rushing ability of Evans, Anderson, and Williams will make third down and long for other teams highly entertaining for Tide fans. This group should be very good against the run, as usual. Phil Steele rates this the top linebacker group in America. I think it’s going to be electrifying to watch.
LB Grade: A+ These guys will create sack after sack and negative play after negative play. It will be something to behold.
Defensive Backs
Again, another elite group for Alabama. Scrimmage observers remarked that finding open receivers look seriously difficult for the quarterbacks. Across the board, coverage was extremely tight. This likely is a result of Saban’s strategy to primarily recruit cornerbacks with cover skills and to then move them to safety as abilities dictate. As a result, Alabama has players on the field with strong cover skills at all times.
It’s time again for another prognostication for the upcoming Alabama football season. Alabama has achieved one of the great dynasties in modern college football history. As winners of four of the last seven national titles, nobody has seen this level of sustained dominance in decades. The Miami Hurricanes (’83, ’87, ’89, & ’91) were the last team to demonstrate so much success. Keep in mind, when Alabama opens 2016 ranked #1, it will constitute the ninth straight year where the Tide has reached the top ranking in nine straight seasons. In the regular season, Alabama has averaged an 11-1 record over the last nine years. Alabama has won three of the last four SEC titles. Alabama is the team of this millennium.
The question: can they do it again this year?
The Caveat
I don’t know anything about the X’s and O’s of football. I just talk and read and collect lots of lots of information. I also do not have time to worry about grammar and typos. Sorry.
Last Year
Pretty stellar. I said I liked Alabama to go 11-1, win the SEC, and beat Baylor for the national title. Pretty right on the money.
Season Comparison
I would compare this season most closely to 2010. That may scare some people. Looking back, the 2010 may have been Saban’s overall most talented group. Alabama had six starters off that defense taken in the 1st round of the NFL draft (with Courtney Upshaw being the first pick of the second round). That team had an elite cadre of skills players and an impressive offensive line. However, that team struggled with apathy following the 2009 national title. The team had lots of players with off the field problems, a sense of entitlement, and several players with their eyes more on the NFL than on winning another national title. Ultimately, that group had Saban’s worst record of the last nine year: 10-3.
In 2016, I think we have a similar situation. Coaches privately have said this is Saban’s most talented Alabama team. Saban subtly in public and more explicitly in private has remarked about a struggle to find good leaders. In the last two years, Saban frequently would talked about how much he liked both the 2014 and 2015 squads. They had strong leadership and good buy in. Saban has not said anything positive yet about liking the feel and leadership of this team. I do not think, however, that this team will go 9-3 in the regular season.
Here’s the difference in my opinion. The 2010 team had a murderous schedule. They played seven opponents with bye weeks before they played Alabama. This year’s schedule is challenging but nothing like 2010. Secondly, Saban and company have dealt with the complacency issues before and know how to handle it better. Finally, the 2010 was not behind it’s quarterback, a central leader on any football team. I get the impression that this year’s eventual starter may be someone the rest of the team will rally behind.
Season in a Nutshell
Alabama will have an historically good defense and compete with the 2011 defense for the title of Saban’s best. Compared to most conservative Alabama offenses, this group will have more upside and downside than normal Saban offenses (which typically seek to limit mistakes at the expense of explosiveness). The Tide will be a dominant team that will make the the playoff through the backdoor.
The Offense
This group may be explosive at times and really struggle at others. I think it will get better as the season progresses and be fun and exciting by the end of the year.
Quarterback
For the third year in a row, a quarterback battle has been the talk of the fall. Out of nowhere, true freshman Jalen Hurts has emerged as an internet legend. I think the legend is true. In both of the scrimmages, Hurts, who was an early entry, has been more successful than any of the quarterbacks at moving the ball and leading drives that end in touchdowns. He has a knack for big plays, both with his feet and through the deep ball, but he also turns the ball over like a true freshman is expected to do. Cooper Bateman, who has been the expected starter as the more experienced player, has not shown the same level of upside as Hurts but has exhibited the same downside. Bateman has thrown multiple interceptions in the scrimmages. Just my opinion, Blake Barnett will never play meaningful snaps and will transfer after this year. He seems to be a player who thrives in 7-on-7, but in real game situations with a pass rush pursuing him, he just doesn’t have it. I could be wrong, but I think Barnett is a non-factor.
I think the QB situation will play out like this. I think the coaches believe Hurts is the best option for the season, and they realize how limited Bateman is. I think they also are afraid to give Hurts too much, too early such that he fails and they damage his confidence (ala Kenny “Trill” Hill and Kyle Allen). I think Bateman will take the first snaps in the first two games, and Hurts will get equal or more snaps throughout those games. I think Hurts will start the Ole Miss game and serve as the primary QB for the remainder of the season. I am buying the hype, and think Hurts will be a star. I think he will be exciting and fun, and will make some really bad decisions during this season.
I should add that I've been totally wrong on the QB situation for two straight years. I thought Sims would be a disaster and Coker would win the job. I thought Bateman would edge out Coker. So your confidence in my opinion should be skeptical at best.
Grade: B with lots of Upside- I could be totally wrong, but I think Hurts will win the job in time and be a very productive player as the season progresses.
Running Back
It is a weird sensation coming into a season at Alabama without a proven, established star running back. I don’t see that star in the stable at this point. Damien Harris seems to be pretty good but not great. Bo Scarborough, who I expected to be a star, does not seem to have won the confidence of the coaches. He has elite athletic talent but does not appear to have emerged as a complete back who can stay healthy. My guess is he will get 6-10 carries per game and will show flashes of greatness, but I personally do not think he is someone who will get 15-20 carries in a game. (Maybe the coaches are just preserving him, knowing that he’s injury prone.) The majority of the early season talk has been around true freshmen B.J. Emmons and Joshua Jacobs, in particular. Jacobs apparently has been the most productive of all the backs.
In this group, I think it will be running back by committee among three players, maybe even four. I don’t expect any star to emerge here but think that the offensive line is good enough that Alabama will have a strong running game.
Grade: B with upside- I think we’ve been spoiled by Coffey, Ingram, Richardson, Lacy, Yeldon, and Henry. Our backs are plenty good, and there are plenty of talented players and our rushing game will be productive because the offensive line is very good.
Receivers
This is an elite unit, perhaps the best we have had at Alabama in my lifetime. Calvin Ridley set the Alabama record for receptions as a freshman and is a preseason first-team All-American. Ardarius Stewart, though he has a penchant for drops, made numerous clutch catches in tight games last year. In re-watching last year, I think we underrate how valuable and productive Stewart is to our team. Robert Foster is also elite, however, I have heard there is concern about how his injury from last year has healed. Grad transfer Gehrig Dieter should be as productive as Richard Mulaney was for Alabama last year. His numbers from Bowling Green were extremely impressive and he is reported to be a better athlete than Mulaney was. Cam Sims has also shown flashes.
Grade: A+ with downside- Numerous publications rate this the top receiver unit in the country. If Foster is not healthy, it could hurt some of the potency of the group.
Tight End
This is surprisingly a great group for Alabama. O.J. Howard is preseason All-SEC. He broke out against Clemson in the national title game. I think his success in the Clemson game will help Howard be more assertive and confident. I also think Kiffin will work to involve Howard in the offense more. Apparently in the preseason scrimmages Howard has caught a lot of passes. Last year, many overlooked the activity of blocking tight end Hale Hentges, who was increasingly effective as the year progressed. Hentges is a reliable blocker and an undervalued player. Brandon Greene has lost a substantial amount of weight and seems poised to have a surprisingly good season for Alabama as a blocker.
Grade: A and steady- I think Howard will have a big season for the Tide. I think we can make too much of the Clemson game where he blew up, largely because he was uncovered. Howard though has always had great upside but has lacked a sense of assertiveness and confidence.
Offensive Line
Alabama recruited offensive line poorly from 2010-2012. As a result, depth and talent were a problem in 2013-14. Mario Cristobal has recruited lights out at OL since coming to Alabama. The Tide is loaded with talent and depth now. With that being said, the Tide also has added Brent Key to serve as the line coach for guards and centers. From what I understand, Cristobal is an elite recruiter and an asset to the staff, but was not the strongest technical offensive line coach. Adding Key to the line I think only will make the group stronger. Cam Robinson is a preseason first team All-American and projected first round pick next year. True freshman Jonah Williams will start at right tackle and is reportedly the next great left tackle for Alabama. Lester Cotton may be my favorite guard prospect of the Saban era. He is an athletic load. I was told that Cotton, who weighs around 320, ran a faster 40yd than all but one player at the NFL Combine among players who weighed 320 or more. I think Cotton will be outstanding. Ross Piersbacher, who was a freshman All-American, has moved from guard to center. I’ve been told that Piersbacher is more of a finesse player than a power blocker, making center a better position for him than guard. There may be some kinks to work out for him as a center but he should do well. The right guard spot has been a fierce competition. It looks as if Bradley Bozeman, a strong and versatile player, will win the job. Fortunately, Alphonse Taylor, Brandon Kennedy, and Dallas Warmack all provide good depth.
Grade: A and steady- Several publications rate this the top offensive line position group in the country. I think the left side of the line will be filthy good with Robinson and Cotton.
Offense Overall Grade: B+ / A- with upside
The offense is a weird situation. You have incredible receivers but the quarterback situation is uncertain. You have a really good offensive line but no discernible feature running back. In the end, I think this will be a balanced and productive offense that will be better overall than the group last year. If Hurts lives up to the hype, look out. We could be in for something special.
Defense
I don’t need to write much here. This is going to be the best defense in the country and will possibly be Saban’s best defense at Alabama. It will rival 2011 in dominance. I listened to a podcast where an insider said that some NFL scouts who have visited Tuscaloosa since the spring have remarked that it’s the fastest and most athletic defense they had seen since Miami 2001. I really do think it may be an “all time” kind of defense.
Defensive Line
This is going to be a great group for the Tide. At defensive end, Jonathan Allen was near the top of the league in sacks last year and will be a first round pick in 2017. Dalvin Tomlinson is quietly a very good contributor. Da’Shawn Hand was the top player in the nation coming out of high school and is poised for a great year. Some think there’s an outside shot that he could have a big year and then jump to the NFL. (I think that’s unlikely but it speaks to how talented he is.) In the middle, Da’Ron Payne is elite. He may be the most important player on the DL. My concern relates to depth in the middle. After Payne, I have not heard anything inspiring (or bad) about O.J. Smith, Dakota Ball, Johnny Dwight, or Josh Frazier (who has the most upside). I worry that against power running teams, depth may hurt us at nose tackle. At the same time, we run a 4-3 pretty often these days, and the lack of depth among true nose tackles may not make a difference. The only newcomer about whom I have heard anything is Raekwon Davis, who appears to be the largest human being ever born. He is 6’7”, 315 pounds and the most imposing freshman I’ve ever seen. There still remain questions about whether he has been cleared academically to compete for Tide.
I think this group will be very good at rushing the passer. I think we should prepare for a bit of a drop off against the run from last year. Keep in mind that Jarran Reed and A’shawn Robinson constituted one of the great run stuffing duos in Alabama football history. The may be more responsible for Derrick Henry winning the Heisman than anyone (see: LSU, Leonard Fournette). In this group, I think Payne and Hand are two emerging stars to watch out for.
DL Grade: A with Downside: An injury to Jonathan Allen or Da’Ron Payne could really hurt this unit. Depth is a concern. The first group, though, is as good as you’ll get in the country.
Linebackers
I’m prone to exaggerate, but this group of linebackers may be my favorite unit ever. College football news has Reuben Foster as a preseason first team All-American and Tim Williams as a second string. Mel Kiper currently has OLD Tim Williams listed as the #2 overall pick for the 2017 draft on his Big Board. He has added some weight and appears set to be more of an every down factor, rather than just a pass rush specialist. From spring scrimmages, a unanimous opinion I’ve heard is that Rashaan Evans has been the most impressive player on the defense. He is an electrifying player who had two sacks in the national title game. On every play, I will have my eyes on #32 (Evans) and #56 (Williams). Meanwhile, the forgotten member of this group, Ryan Anderson, may be the most productive overall player in the group. He had six sacks and 11.5 tackles for loss in 2015. I also have heard that Anfernee Jennings and Christian Miller provide valuable depth and have bright futures.
The exciting development for me is that Evans and Williams have both developed such that these four (Anderson, Evans, Williams, and Foster) likely will be able to stay on the field for all three downs on most occasions. Altogether, I’ve never been more excited about a group of linebackers as an Alabama fan. The pass rushing ability of Evans, Anderson, and Williams will make third down and long for other teams highly entertaining for Tide fans. This group should be very good against the run, as usual. Phil Steele rates this the top linebacker group in America. I think it’s going to be electrifying to watch.
LB Grade: A+ These guys will create sack after sack and negative play after negative play. It will be something to behold.
Defensive Backs
Again, another elite group for Alabama. Scrimmage observers remarked that finding open receivers look seriously difficult for the quarterbacks. Across the board, coverage was extremely tight. This likely is a result of Saban’s strategy to primarily recruit cornerbacks with cover skills and to then move them to safety as abilities dictate. As a result, Alabama has players on the field with strong cover skills at all times.
Marlon Humphrey likely will play his final year at Alabama, as many project he will be a first round pick next year. Minkah Fitzpatrick could be on his way to being regarded as one of the all-time greats at Alabama. He was an outstanding player for Alabama as a true freshman last year. People have said that Anthony Averette, who is the very fastest player on the team, has not just looked liked a serviceable option at corner, but he has looked good. As a result, Minkah likely will be able to play nickel back, his preferred position, for much of the year. Ronnie Harrison was another outstanding freshman last year. Hootie Jones appears to have become a reliable option at strong safety, particularly for situations against power-running teams. Eddie Jackson has been named to some first team All-American lists and is projected as a first round draft pick by some publications for the 2017 NFL Draft.
There is not a tremendous amount of experienced depth with Kendall Sheffield and Mo Smith taking their services (along their bankies, diaper bags, Desitin, and pacifiers) with them. However, the new batch of freshman — particularly Mayden, Carter, and Diggs — all have received rave reviews from insiders.
DB Grade: A+ and steady Injuries may hurt this group, but the new freshmen seem to be very, very good. This group was outstanding last year and will only improve this year.
Overall Defensive Grade: A+
Phil Steele rates two of the position groups #1 in the nation (LB’s and DL) and the other #2 (DB’s). I think it will be something special to treasure. It will be extraordinarily hard for teams to keep Evans, Williams, Allen, Hand, and Anderson out of the backfield. In passing situations, quarterbacks will have very little time and very little comfort in the pocket due to the pass rush. Keep in mind, Alabama lead the country in sacks last year with fifty-three. And I think this group will be stronger in pass rushing than last year’s crew.
Meanwhile, Alabama has, in my opinion, the best secondary in the country. Fitzpatrick and Humphrey are both elite, first-round caliber players. Eddie Jackson and Ronnie Harrison are impressive playmakers. I think teams will struggle to find open receivers and this group will again rank very highly nationally in team interceptions and pass efficiency defense. (They were 9th in the country last year.)
The only weak link for the Tide, in my opinion, will be against power running teams. I think a team like LSU with a good offensive line and a great running back may be able to run the ball between the tackles against the Tide. Depth and skill at NT and DT (when in 4-3) drop off pretty dramatically after Da’Ron Payne in my opinion.
I tend to think about talent in terms of who will be drafted into the NFL within two years. In 2011, Alabama’s historically good defense, five players were ultimately taken in the first round off of that group. I think it is reasonable to project that nine players (Evans, Foster, Williams, Allen, Hand, Jackson, Fitzpatrick, Payne, and Humphrey) will be taken in the first round in either the 2016 or 2017 drafts. That is freaky good.
The Schedule
The schedule this year is hot and cold. The SEC West is not particularly good this year. Mississippi State and Arkansas should take a step back. I don’t think Auburn will improve much from the team that went 2-6 in the conference last year. I think Texas A&M could be surprisingly good but still not great. I think LSU and Ole Miss are the lone teams in the West who are Top 15 teams nationally. The downside to the schedule is Alabama catches its three hardest opponents — Ole Miss, LSU, and Tennessee - on the road. Fortunately, there is no murderers row as in the past, where Alabama played four ranked opponents in a row. (Last year it was UGA, Arkansas, TAM, and Tennessee in four straight weeks.)
USC
I think Alabama fans are underrating and overlooking USC. They have elite talent. I don’t know much about their new coach. They are very good on the lines and have a highly rated new starter at quarterback. I think this will be a competitive game through the fourth quarter that Alabama wins by a touchdown or less.
WIN
Western Kentucky
How many snaps will Hurts v. Bateman play in this one?
WIN
Ole Miss
In everyone’s “notice” of Ole Miss’ sudden spike in elite talent from around the country since Hugh Freeze took over, people overlook that the Rebel staff has done a good job coaching. Their defense tackles really well. They get the most out of their skills players. They win a lot of games. This year, Ole Miss has the best quarterback in the SEC. Chad Kelly is a really, really good passer and athlete. Even though Treadwell is gone, the Rebels still have good receivers. I think Alabama gets Ole Miss at the right time, though. The Rebs have a young offensive line. They also have a below average running attack. I think Alabama will be in the backfield all day, and Kelly will struggle to get in a rhythm. Meanwhile, I think Hurts will be starting at this point. I think Alabama will be able to run the ball on Ole Miss.
Last year the Tide came out too hyped up for this game by their own admission. I think they’ll probably learn from that experience and come out motivated but more poised. Keep in mind, Alabama gave Ole Miss the ball five times within their own 30 yard line in 2015. Ole Miss also scored one touchdown off of a complete fluke play (the off the helmet deflection) and an awful blown call (pop pass with offensive lineman seven yards down field). With that mound of breaks and luck, Alabama still had the ball with a few minutes to play and a chance to win the game. I think Alabama wins this year. I like the Tide to cover.
WIN
Kent State
Kent State plays good football. Alabama will win this game but coming off the Ole Miss game, I would expect a letdown.
WIN
Kentucky
The Cats just aren’t very good. I can see Alabama winning this game by forty points, and I also can see Alabama sleep walking to an uninspiring win. Regardless, this is a W.
WIN
Arkansas
Arkansas is a little down this year. They lose a lot of players from last year’s squad. Brett Bielma is a really good coach. They play a style of football that Alabama does not match up as well against this year. Fayetteville is a tough, tough place to play. Still, I don't see how Arkansas is able to score much at all. I think the Hogs will keep it ugly, keep it close, and Alabama will get an ugly win.
WIN
Tennessee
This will be one of the games of the year in college football. Tennessee returns the fourth most experienced team in America. Butch Jones has amassed a lot of talent. There is a new confidence on Rocky Top. Many are talking about how UT was four plays away last year from being in the national title game. (I think we said that in the Shula years.) All jokes aside they played everyone on their schedule very, very tight. They bring back a dangerous quarterback.
I think Alabama is going to win this game. They normally prop up their feet at the Atlantis before playing the Tide. This year, however, Tennessee comes off a very tough stretch of games entering the Alabama game. They’ll be the fatigued group in this match up. I also think Alabama’s defense will match up extremely well against spread option teams like the Vols. Finally, I think Butch Jones is a good recruiter and program builder, but I think he’s a miserable game coach. I think Saban will outmatch him in this game.
WIN
Texas A&M
This is a big trap game for Alabama. It comes off two tough road games. The Tennessee game will be emotional, win or lose. TAM has a great group of receivers. I think transfer quarterback, Brandon Knight, could be effective here. Again, I think the Tide matches up extremely well against teams that are “pass first.” I also don’t believe that the TAM defense can keep a team like Alabama below thirty points. I’m thankful that this game is at home. I expect a tough game, but I think Alabama will win.
WIN
LSU
Unless things unravel for LSU during the season, and I don’t think they will, I think this game is a loss for Alabama. LSU has the seventh most experienced team in the country. They bring back outstanding receivers and one of the three best players in the country, Leonard Fournette. Their offensive line will be strong. Alabama benefited from LSU’s dreadful defensive coordinator hire, Kevin Steele, last year. This year the Tigers bring in Dave Aranda, who is one of the very best defensive minds in college football. Keep in mind how hard it has been for Alabama to beat LSU in Baton Rouge. In 2008, the game went to overtime. In 2010, Alabama last to an average LSU team. In 2012, Alabama had to win in the last 30 second. In 2014, Alabama caught some breaks to push the game into overtime, where they won. With the exception of 2008, LSU should have won the last three match ups in Baton Rouge. Alabama has had much better teams in those year, but LSU has risen to the occasion and played their best games against the Tide in the bayou. I think the Bayou Bengals will be on a mission this year. I think they’ll play hard for their nearly canned coach, Les Miles. I think the floods will serve as motivation as well. I, also, think they’ll be able to exploit Alabama’s lack of bulk up the middle on defense to establish an inside running game. That is the first step in beating Alabama. I just think the Tigers will get the upper hand in this game. I think it will resemble the other games — very tight — but LSU will be able to finish the deal this year.
LOSS
Mississippi State
I think losing Dak Prescott will really affect the Bullies. I don’t foresee Mississippi State being able to move the ball on or score against Alabama. Meanwhile, the Tide should be able to get enough points to win comfortably. After the LSU loss, I think Alabama will gain new life when they either don’t fall out of the Top 4, or they are right on the fringe. This should help the Tide find motivation to press on and finish well.
WIN
Chattanooga
I love taking my daughter to this game. It’s cool outside. I don’t have to pay attention to the game. It’s the best game to take a toddler to. Can’t wait.
WIN
Auburn
I struggle to find a solid argument for Auburn being a particularly competitive team this year. They have some great true freshmen receivers. Shaun White is generally a pretty good passing quarterback. The Tigers have a really good set of guards and a solid center. At the same time, there are some realities on this team that make me think that Auburn is at best an 8-4 team. First, with Jovon Robinson off the team, Auburn will play their former H-Back as their #2 option at running back. That’s never a good sign for running back talent or depth. They have two new tackles on offense. On defense, they have six five-star defensive linemen, including three who were Top 5 players overall nationally. Yet their D-line was average last year and Phil Steele ranks it the ninth best DL group in the SEC. This speaks to dreadful player development. Finally, Auburn hired Kevin Steele to replace Will Muschamp. Steele is a great guy and a good LB coach, but he is a really bad defensive coordinator. Finally, their secondary, which has been a weak spot for several years, is weaker than last year. Auburn tends to thrive when expectations are low, but I just don’t see the personnel, either on the coaching staff or on the field, for Auburn to put together an unexpected miracle team, ala 2010 or 2013.
WIN
Regular Season Record: 11-1
How’s It Going to End?
I think this will be a dominant Alabama team. The defense will be extremely good. Teams will struggle mightily to score twenty points in any contest. Meanwhile, the Tide offensive line is good enough that Alabama will be able to churn out enough points to win games. If Jalen Hurts develops, I think the offense could be explosive at times, especially as the year progresses. Hurts brings something to the game with his feet that we have not seen at Alabama under Saban, except with Blake Sims. He also has the ability with his arm to utilize the rich talent at receiver. If the Alabama offense excels, then this team will be insanely good.
As good as LSU may be, I think there are two losses in their season with one of those possibly coming in the SEC Championship Game. I think with road wins at Tennessee and Ole Miss and with an early season win versus a solid USC team, Alabama will make the Final Four, perhaps as a non-champion. In the playoff, I like Alabama to win it all. The season ends with everyone hating the Tide, just the way we like it!
Final Prediction: Alabama 13-1 (or 14-1) and National Champions
There is not a tremendous amount of experienced depth with Kendall Sheffield and Mo Smith taking their services (along their bankies, diaper bags, Desitin, and pacifiers) with them. However, the new batch of freshman — particularly Mayden, Carter, and Diggs — all have received rave reviews from insiders.
DB Grade: A+ and steady Injuries may hurt this group, but the new freshmen seem to be very, very good. This group was outstanding last year and will only improve this year.
Overall Defensive Grade: A+
Phil Steele rates two of the position groups #1 in the nation (LB’s and DL) and the other #2 (DB’s). I think it will be something special to treasure. It will be extraordinarily hard for teams to keep Evans, Williams, Allen, Hand, and Anderson out of the backfield. In passing situations, quarterbacks will have very little time and very little comfort in the pocket due to the pass rush. Keep in mind, Alabama lead the country in sacks last year with fifty-three. And I think this group will be stronger in pass rushing than last year’s crew.
Meanwhile, Alabama has, in my opinion, the best secondary in the country. Fitzpatrick and Humphrey are both elite, first-round caliber players. Eddie Jackson and Ronnie Harrison are impressive playmakers. I think teams will struggle to find open receivers and this group will again rank very highly nationally in team interceptions and pass efficiency defense. (They were 9th in the country last year.)
The only weak link for the Tide, in my opinion, will be against power running teams. I think a team like LSU with a good offensive line and a great running back may be able to run the ball between the tackles against the Tide. Depth and skill at NT and DT (when in 4-3) drop off pretty dramatically after Da’Ron Payne in my opinion.
I tend to think about talent in terms of who will be drafted into the NFL within two years. In 2011, Alabama’s historically good defense, five players were ultimately taken in the first round off of that group. I think it is reasonable to project that nine players (Evans, Foster, Williams, Allen, Hand, Jackson, Fitzpatrick, Payne, and Humphrey) will be taken in the first round in either the 2016 or 2017 drafts. That is freaky good.
The Schedule
The schedule this year is hot and cold. The SEC West is not particularly good this year. Mississippi State and Arkansas should take a step back. I don’t think Auburn will improve much from the team that went 2-6 in the conference last year. I think Texas A&M could be surprisingly good but still not great. I think LSU and Ole Miss are the lone teams in the West who are Top 15 teams nationally. The downside to the schedule is Alabama catches its three hardest opponents — Ole Miss, LSU, and Tennessee - on the road. Fortunately, there is no murderers row as in the past, where Alabama played four ranked opponents in a row. (Last year it was UGA, Arkansas, TAM, and Tennessee in four straight weeks.)
USC
I think Alabama fans are underrating and overlooking USC. They have elite talent. I don’t know much about their new coach. They are very good on the lines and have a highly rated new starter at quarterback. I think this will be a competitive game through the fourth quarter that Alabama wins by a touchdown or less.
WIN
Western Kentucky
How many snaps will Hurts v. Bateman play in this one?
WIN
Ole Miss
In everyone’s “notice” of Ole Miss’ sudden spike in elite talent from around the country since Hugh Freeze took over, people overlook that the Rebel staff has done a good job coaching. Their defense tackles really well. They get the most out of their skills players. They win a lot of games. This year, Ole Miss has the best quarterback in the SEC. Chad Kelly is a really, really good passer and athlete. Even though Treadwell is gone, the Rebels still have good receivers. I think Alabama gets Ole Miss at the right time, though. The Rebs have a young offensive line. They also have a below average running attack. I think Alabama will be in the backfield all day, and Kelly will struggle to get in a rhythm. Meanwhile, I think Hurts will be starting at this point. I think Alabama will be able to run the ball on Ole Miss.
Last year the Tide came out too hyped up for this game by their own admission. I think they’ll probably learn from that experience and come out motivated but more poised. Keep in mind, Alabama gave Ole Miss the ball five times within their own 30 yard line in 2015. Ole Miss also scored one touchdown off of a complete fluke play (the off the helmet deflection) and an awful blown call (pop pass with offensive lineman seven yards down field). With that mound of breaks and luck, Alabama still had the ball with a few minutes to play and a chance to win the game. I think Alabama wins this year. I like the Tide to cover.
WIN
Kent State
Kent State plays good football. Alabama will win this game but coming off the Ole Miss game, I would expect a letdown.
WIN
Kentucky
The Cats just aren’t very good. I can see Alabama winning this game by forty points, and I also can see Alabama sleep walking to an uninspiring win. Regardless, this is a W.
WIN
Arkansas
Arkansas is a little down this year. They lose a lot of players from last year’s squad. Brett Bielma is a really good coach. They play a style of football that Alabama does not match up as well against this year. Fayetteville is a tough, tough place to play. Still, I don't see how Arkansas is able to score much at all. I think the Hogs will keep it ugly, keep it close, and Alabama will get an ugly win.
WIN
Tennessee
This will be one of the games of the year in college football. Tennessee returns the fourth most experienced team in America. Butch Jones has amassed a lot of talent. There is a new confidence on Rocky Top. Many are talking about how UT was four plays away last year from being in the national title game. (I think we said that in the Shula years.) All jokes aside they played everyone on their schedule very, very tight. They bring back a dangerous quarterback.
I think Alabama is going to win this game. They normally prop up their feet at the Atlantis before playing the Tide. This year, however, Tennessee comes off a very tough stretch of games entering the Alabama game. They’ll be the fatigued group in this match up. I also think Alabama’s defense will match up extremely well against spread option teams like the Vols. Finally, I think Butch Jones is a good recruiter and program builder, but I think he’s a miserable game coach. I think Saban will outmatch him in this game.
WIN
Texas A&M
This is a big trap game for Alabama. It comes off two tough road games. The Tennessee game will be emotional, win or lose. TAM has a great group of receivers. I think transfer quarterback, Brandon Knight, could be effective here. Again, I think the Tide matches up extremely well against teams that are “pass first.” I also don’t believe that the TAM defense can keep a team like Alabama below thirty points. I’m thankful that this game is at home. I expect a tough game, but I think Alabama will win.
WIN
LSU
Unless things unravel for LSU during the season, and I don’t think they will, I think this game is a loss for Alabama. LSU has the seventh most experienced team in the country. They bring back outstanding receivers and one of the three best players in the country, Leonard Fournette. Their offensive line will be strong. Alabama benefited from LSU’s dreadful defensive coordinator hire, Kevin Steele, last year. This year the Tigers bring in Dave Aranda, who is one of the very best defensive minds in college football. Keep in mind how hard it has been for Alabama to beat LSU in Baton Rouge. In 2008, the game went to overtime. In 2010, Alabama last to an average LSU team. In 2012, Alabama had to win in the last 30 second. In 2014, Alabama caught some breaks to push the game into overtime, where they won. With the exception of 2008, LSU should have won the last three match ups in Baton Rouge. Alabama has had much better teams in those year, but LSU has risen to the occasion and played their best games against the Tide in the bayou. I think the Bayou Bengals will be on a mission this year. I think they’ll play hard for their nearly canned coach, Les Miles. I think the floods will serve as motivation as well. I, also, think they’ll be able to exploit Alabama’s lack of bulk up the middle on defense to establish an inside running game. That is the first step in beating Alabama. I just think the Tigers will get the upper hand in this game. I think it will resemble the other games — very tight — but LSU will be able to finish the deal this year.
LOSS
Mississippi State
I think losing Dak Prescott will really affect the Bullies. I don’t foresee Mississippi State being able to move the ball on or score against Alabama. Meanwhile, the Tide should be able to get enough points to win comfortably. After the LSU loss, I think Alabama will gain new life when they either don’t fall out of the Top 4, or they are right on the fringe. This should help the Tide find motivation to press on and finish well.
WIN
Chattanooga
I love taking my daughter to this game. It’s cool outside. I don’t have to pay attention to the game. It’s the best game to take a toddler to. Can’t wait.
WIN
Auburn
I struggle to find a solid argument for Auburn being a particularly competitive team this year. They have some great true freshmen receivers. Shaun White is generally a pretty good passing quarterback. The Tigers have a really good set of guards and a solid center. At the same time, there are some realities on this team that make me think that Auburn is at best an 8-4 team. First, with Jovon Robinson off the team, Auburn will play their former H-Back as their #2 option at running back. That’s never a good sign for running back talent or depth. They have two new tackles on offense. On defense, they have six five-star defensive linemen, including three who were Top 5 players overall nationally. Yet their D-line was average last year and Phil Steele ranks it the ninth best DL group in the SEC. This speaks to dreadful player development. Finally, Auburn hired Kevin Steele to replace Will Muschamp. Steele is a great guy and a good LB coach, but he is a really bad defensive coordinator. Finally, their secondary, which has been a weak spot for several years, is weaker than last year. Auburn tends to thrive when expectations are low, but I just don’t see the personnel, either on the coaching staff or on the field, for Auburn to put together an unexpected miracle team, ala 2010 or 2013.
WIN
Regular Season Record: 11-1
How’s It Going to End?
I think this will be a dominant Alabama team. The defense will be extremely good. Teams will struggle mightily to score twenty points in any contest. Meanwhile, the Tide offensive line is good enough that Alabama will be able to churn out enough points to win games. If Jalen Hurts develops, I think the offense could be explosive at times, especially as the year progresses. Hurts brings something to the game with his feet that we have not seen at Alabama under Saban, except with Blake Sims. He also has the ability with his arm to utilize the rich talent at receiver. If the Alabama offense excels, then this team will be insanely good.
As good as LSU may be, I think there are two losses in their season with one of those possibly coming in the SEC Championship Game. I think with road wins at Tennessee and Ole Miss and with an early season win versus a solid USC team, Alabama will make the Final Four, perhaps as a non-champion. In the playoff, I like Alabama to win it all. The season ends with everyone hating the Tide, just the way we like it!
Final Prediction: Alabama 13-1 (or 14-1) and National Champions