It’s that time again for the 22nd (highly amateur edition) of my Alabama football prognostication. Time is pretty limited right now. Nevertheless, duty calls and I’m good to dump what I’ve read, heard, and thought about the Tide’s upcoming season.
Alabama enters the year ranked #1. This marks the 14th season in a row where the Tide has been ranked #1 at some point in the season. Expectations are high, per usual. Simultaneously, I do not think Alabama fans have accounted for just how significant the losses on the offensive side of the ball are as it relates to 2021.
The Tide has progressed to a point where the fan base thinks in terms of “national championship or not” as the standard. It makes sense. Alabama has entered November controlling its own destiny for the national title for 13 straight years. Alabama has won 6 of the last 12 national championships. They’ve played in 8 of the last 12 title games. If you’re a kid entering the eighth grade, only four times in your life has Bama not been in the title game. Wow. It’s staggering.
But to sanitize a quote by Nick Saban, much like with linebackers, you don’t just “spit” out championships. Factors and personnel have to line up. And you have to get lucky on the injury front.
Alabama will have the best defense in the nation. The personnel, depth, and experience are remarkable.
Meanwhile, the offense will take a major step down. People need to recognize three important things. First, in 2017, 2018, and 2019, Alabama had four players in the rotation who eventually were drafted in the first round. In 2020, they started two such players. In 2021, it does not seem likely that that is true of anyone at this point.
Secondly, the 2020 offensive line was as good if not better than the 2012 offensive group, as blasphemous as that may sound. In 2021, there is quite a bit of inexperience, although there is plenty of talent.
And third, people just cannot appreciate how exceptional the quarterback play was from 2017 through 2020. Alabama had two quarterbacks taken in the top 15 picks of the NFL draft. That’s unheard of in my lifetime. Tua was a once in a generation talent and Mac Jones had a once in a generation type season. Meanwhile, the back up options included Mac, Jaylen, who is an NFL starter, and Bryce, who was the top quarterback in the nation coming out of high school. I think Bryce young, is a very exciting play maker, but I do not think he is a once in a generation talent.
All of these factors leave quite a number of questions about the offense. The expectation that we will automatically score 45 or more points per game are not realistic. Anything is possible. Certainly the coaching and personnel are very good. Still I do not think it is feasible that this team comes out every game and puts up staggering points like the teams for the last three years.
The Season in a Sentence
Alabama’s defense and talent will make it a contender, but can all of the questionable pieces on offense fit together to win a championship?
The Caveat
I know nothing about the X’s and O’s of football. I read, listen, and talk about Alabama football daily. My parents paid an extraordinary amount of money for me to major in English and Latin and I’ve been trying to justify that liberal arts education ever since then. But, boy, I nailed it pretty good last year. :-)
THE OFFENSE
Alabama fans should expect a return to smash-mouth, run-first offense after four years of a high-flying passing assault.
Quarterback
Bryce Young is a playmaker. He’s not super comfortable or natural in the pocket. He’s electric when get scrambles. Unlike Jalen Hurts who wanted to run, he uses scrambling to open up the passing game. Coaches seem pleased with him. I predict that he’ll be prone to some slumps and streaks and won’t have the kind of consistency and efficiency that we’ve grown accustomed to over the last three years. If Bryce goes down we are in big trouble. And that is something to consider as slight as Bryce is and as much as he runs. Paul Tyson has improved a great deal. He’s a really nice back up option but not a QB who could take Alabama to an SEC or national championship from end to end. Jalen Milroe has incredible upside as a runner,passer, and leader but he has a long way to go reading defenses. If he stays around and is faithful to the process he could be a star in 2-3 years.
Grade: A- / B+ : Good with Downside - Bryce is not Mac or Tua but he’s certainly better than Jalen Hurts, especially in the passing game. He’s very exciting although I think it will take some time before we can rely on him to be consistent and efficient.
Running Backs
This is the best unit on the offense. Tide fans can expect running back by committee similar to the situation in 2018. Brian Robinson will get the start and do a good enough job. Jase McClellan seems to be a home run hitter who pulls out lot of long runs. Trey Sanders has looked really good in the fall, running both inside and outside. (I personally think Jase and Trey are our best two backs. Robinson has much value from a leadership and experience standpoint is and really good in the red zone.) Roydell looked really good in the scrimmage. It’s possible that he will redshirt just as a matter of preserving his eligibility since there are jut so many good backs and only so much playing time. Camar Wheaton, the five star true freshman, is one of the most talented athletes on the team. He may return kicks but is likely destined for a redshirt. He has limited technical skills as a RB and has much learning to do.
Grade - A : Very Good - This is one of the best RB units in the country. I think 3-4 of them will shine as they share carries.
Wide Receiver
I already alluded to just how exceptional this unit has been over the previous four seasons. There just is not an obvious star that requires the defense’s intense attention at this point. Metchie is a really good player but I’m not sure how productive he can be as a #1 featured receiver. Slade Bolden is underrated as a route runner and he’s certainly not someone who has the ability to create space against an elite CB. Jameson Williamson has been the talk of camp. He’s perhaps the fastest player on the team and is a constant deep threat. (I think he’s a poor man’s Sammie Coates in that he just runs deep and causes lots of damage with 1-3 deep balls per game.) JoJo Earl has had a great summer, has a lot of juice and bounce, and could emerge as the freshman star we are looking for. Agiyaye Hall has elite talent, had a great spring, but has been quiet in the fall. He too could emerge as the needed playmaker. I think Thaiu Jones-Bell is underrated and can be a playmaker. Holden can get open but has a bad case of the drops. I’m not sure that Javon Baker ever becomes relevant in the rotation.
The rise of JoJo Earl to “co-starter” on the depth chart is significant. He is a dangerous player. A line up of Bolden, Metchie, and Williamson is not terribly menacing for defenses to defend. But the playmaking ability of early adds a dangerous element. If Earl proves to be super freshman, then this group’s grade can rise markedly.
Grade - B : Good with upside. Right now this group is good but has remarkable upside. They need someone to emerge as a star and for a young player or two to step forward as a playmaker. Both of these are certainly possible.
Tight End
This unit has the potential to be very good but the delinquency of a star among the tight ends is jeopardizing that status. Cameron Latu improved as much as any player on the team in the offseason. He’s a strong blocker at the point of attack and a surprisingly good receiver. He could be a serious weapon in the red zone. Billingsley could be the most valuable weapon on the offense and is at worst a second round pick in the draft. However, he has worked his way into the doghouse and seems to be making matters worse rather than better. As the season progresses, I think you can look for Kendall Randolph to end up here as a run blocker in run situations.
Grade - A - : Very Good - This group really should be an A, and the best tight end units of the Saban era. Bill O’Brien has a history of using tight ends very effectively. So much depends upon Billingsley’s ability to do the right things and to get back in Saban’s good graces.
Offensive Line
To me, the progress of the offensive line will write the destiny of Alabama’s season. This group is not as inexperienced as people say. Neal is a first round draft pick, first team All SEC, and two-year starter at left tackle. Behind Will Anderson, he’s probably the second best player on the whole team. Ekiyor at right guard is a really solid blocker, returning starter, and one who played plenty before this year. Chris Owens, who’s had a somewhat disappointing fall, has played a lot of football at Alabama. He’s smart, capable, and experienced. Not a star but good enough. Javion Cohen at left guard is a really, really good athlete but only in his second year. Right tackle is the position of highest interest. Kendall Randolph is slated as the starter but I don’t expect him to remain there for the whole season. JC Latham is a future star (#3 player in America coming out of high school) who many people expect to win the job as the season progresses. Chris Owens may end up playing a fair amount at RT. Darrian Dalcourt has emerged at center and could be a star. He has two years as a reserve under his belt, and many considered him the top center in the country coming out of high school.
Grade - B+ : Good - Altogether, I think this group will be good to very good at run blocking. I also think they will struggle quite a bit in pass protection. It wouldn’t surprise me to see Bryce Young running for his life in several games this year.
Overall Offensive Grade: B+ Good with Upside - I think the Alabama offense will be able to run the ball effectively. There is the chance that the offensive line gels better than I expect, that some playmakers and / or stars emerge at receiver, and that Bryce is more transcendent than I expect. It’s all possible. And, there are a lot of “if” based conditions in that last sentence. Three major factors have to fall into place for this to be championship caliber offense and that’s a little too much “if-ing” for me. I think this group runs well but struggles in the passing game for much of the season. I think Bryce will provide some thrilling moments; he’s truly electric. I think inconsistency in the passing game will be the Achilles heel of this team, particularly in the biggest games.
THE DEFENSE
I consider the 2016 defense the gold standard of the Saban era. Behind that I would place 2011 and 2009. I think the 2021 defense could be in the neighborhood of 2009 or 2011 if one piece falls in place. This is statistically the most experienced defense of the Saban era. Alabama brings back eight starters, and the replacement for one of those is Henry To’o To’o, who started for two seasons at UT and was considered one of the top LBs in the conference. Let’s take a look at the positions. Last year, Alabama’s defense led the conference in scoring defense and it will be considerably better in 2021. It sets up well for the Tide to have a dominant defense by 2021 standards.
Defensive Line
There aren’t any obvious stars in the interior line, but there are a lot of reliable, experienced players. I think Young and Dale are fine. Egbogbie apparently does his job consistently and well and enables linebackers to make plays. None of the guys are sexy or makes tons of plays but they’re reliable. Phil Mathis seems primed to have a big year. To me the key is the Dancing Bear, Tim Smith. Smith has star potential. He could be the next great interior lineman; he made a lot of plays last year. If Tim Smith can live into that potential, then this defense could enter 2009 / 2011. Jah’Marien Latham is a younger player worth watching.
Grade - A- : This will be a solid group. I think Phil Mathis and Tim Smith will provide enough of a playmaking presence to round out the defensive line as a very good group.
Linebackers
This is probably the best linebacker group Alabama has had since 2016. On CBS, Alabama has three first-team All SEC linebackers: Christian Harris, Henry To’o To’o, and Will Anderson. In the middle, many regard To’o To’o as the best LB in the conference last year. Harris is a third year starter. Both appear to be good blitzers. Jalen Moody will play plenty and provide valuable depth; I think he starts at 2/3’s of SEC programs this year. Very smart and great nose for the ball.
On the outside, the Tide likely has the best outside linebackers in the country. Will Anderson is probably the best player on Alabama’s team and one of the most dangerous edge rushers in the country. Chris Allen is really underrated and really solid both in rush defense and as a pass rush. Former five-star, Drew Sanders, appears to be the first off the bench, and he looked pretty filthy in the scrimmages. Chris Braswell also may contribute. Dallas Turner is a future star.
Grade - A+ : Great. This group is elite, reminiscent of the 2016 group. Best unit in the country. Should be exciting to watch.
Defensive Backs
Alabama loses its star in Patrick Surtain, but this again is another excellent group. Josh Jobe and Malachi Moore are both preseason first team All-SEC. Jordan Battle projects to go in the 1-2 rounds in the draft. Many have said that Demarco Hellum (who has been banged up) and Brian Branch have both had very good fall camps. I haven’t heard a word about Daniel Wright this spring, who was a solid contributor last year (although maligned at times). Jalyn Armour-Davis seems to have wrapped up the other corner spot. People have raved about Kool-Aid McKinstry, who is regarded as a rising star who may win the job.
Grade - A : Very Good - The safeties in this group are elite across the board. Josh Jobe could work his way into the first round this year. The only weakness is the other corner position, but that position will be fine. I think this is one of the best secondaries in the country.
Overall Defensive Grade: A / A+ : Very good to Great. The linebackers are exceptional. The secondary great. The only thing this defense lacks is an interior pass rush from the defensive line. If Mathis and Tim Smith can take the next type forward, then this could be an all-time group in the neighborhood of 2009 and 2011. In this age of explosive offenses, there will not be any insane stats like allowing only 10 points per game. Still, this defense could create challenges even for the best teams.
THE SCHEDULE
Alabama has a tough schedule with some very challenging road games. Here’s a short look.
Miami - A great helmet game. Who will ever forget the ’89 and ’93 Sugar Bowls. Miami’s QB King is really, really good and will create problems for Bama. Miami’s front seven was gutted and is awful, after a season where it finished 79th in rush defense. Alabama will run the ball well and win in the double digits.
Mercer - Should be ugly early and a good chance to see some of the young talent.
Florida - Going to Gainesville is always difficult. Florida lost so many key players on offense and on defense. Still, Dan Mullen seems to gameplan very well for Alabama. I think this will be a tough game that the Tide wins in a less comfortable manner than we would like.
Southern Miss - The Eagles used to be a “hold your breath” game every year. They beat the Tide in ’82, ’90, and ’00. But the landscape of football has changed a great deal and Alabama will wreck the Eagle.
Ole Miss- One of the most dangerous games on the schedule. Kiffin will have an explosive offense that can outscore Alabama. These are the games where Alabama is vulnerable. As good as the Tide defense is, one can expect Ole Miss to score in the 30’s or more. If Alabama has a bad day on offense, they could easily lose.
Texas A&M - Many people see this as the toughest game of the year. TAM has great talent in key places, especially on the defensive line. Young players on the OL and QB make this loud road test difficult. Still, I’ll believe TAM under Jimbo Fisher beats Alabama when I see it. In spite of their electric RBs, I think their offense is not terribly menacing. Alabama wins.
Mississippi St. - In Mike Leach’s second year, he will knock off some good opponent, but it won’t be Alabama. Terrible match up for the Bulldogs, especially against Alabama’s secondary.
Tennessee - This will be ugly. The Vols talent level is deplorable. It wouldn't surprise me if UT goes 1-7 or 0-8 in the conference. Alabama gets its 15th in a row over the Vols with a large margin of victory.
LSU - I think LSU will be better than people expect. I think playing at home helps Alabama get the win here, but I expect it to be a hard fought, close game.
New Mexico State - Great game to take a young child too. It will be 21-0 ten minutes in and you can just pay attention to the baby. Great game to take the kids too. Poor NMSU. This will be so painfully ugly.
Arkansas - Really well coached team that just doesn’t have much talent yet. Alabama should win comfortably at home.
Auburn - First year coaches at Auburn historically tend to overachieve. Auburn has the best RB in the SEC and an experienced OL. I think Bo Nix will live into his potential more with better coaching. On defense they have several All-SEC players. Auburn has some nice players. However, Gus managed his roster very poorly and left Harsin with a limited overall talent base and very little depth. I think Alabama is a bad match up for them. Their receivers are below average and the Tide will be able to stack the box. Meanwhile, their defensive line leaves a lot to be desired and I think Alabama will be able to run the ball on them. I think this Auburn team could be one that gets worse rather than better as the season goes on as a product of poor depth. Getting Auburn late is probably to Alabama's benefit. Auburn could roll out 22 toddlers in Jordan Hare, and I’d be nervous. I do think Alabama will win an ugly, close game on the road here.
How’s It Going to Go?
I want to suggest three scenarios and then predict how I think it’s going to go.
Scenario #1: Alabama wins the national title if……
(1) The pieces come together on offense. The offensive line gels, protects Bryce, and provides for a consistent running game.
(2) A dangerous freshman receiver, like JoJo Earl, emerges as a weapon.
(3) Bryce Young proves to be a third team All SEC type player as a result of basic efficiency and playmaking.
(4) The defensive line gets interior pass rush.
Alabama has the talent to win the national title. The defense will be the best in the country. If this team comes out v. Miami and then Florida, and puts up at least 42-45 points in both of those games and looks explosive, I think you can blow out the candles. They’ll win it all. The offense will only get better as the season progresses. If they start out with that level of production, they’ll have the ability to outscore elite offenses in the playoffs.
Scenario #2: Alabama makes the playoff, but loses two games and doesn’t win the title if….
(1) The offense struggles in the passing game due to young receivers, a newish line, and Bryce not being terribly efficient.
The defense has a ton of depth is going to be great regardless. Between the defense and the running attack, this team can make it to the playoff and win the SEC. However, without an explosive passing game, in the playoffs they will encounter a team that they’ll need to outscore, and simply won’t be able to do it.
Scenario #3: Alabama goes 10-2 and doesn’t make the playoffs if….
(1) Bryce Young gets injured in the first third of the season.
Bryce is really good, and there is just nothing behind him now. Paul Tyson has improved a lot and can help Bama beat most of the teams on the regular season schedule. Milroe is definitely not ready to start. His ability to read defenses at this point would make him a liability were he to have to start. Bryce Young getting injured would derail the whole season.
What’s Going to Happen
I think Scenario #2 is the outcome for the 2021 campaign. I think Alabama will have one game where they need to outscore an opponent and simply can’t and another game where the offense is really flat against a good opposing defense and they lose a close one. I think the former loss will be against an explosive team like Ole Miss (regular season) or Oklahoma in the playoff. The latter loss could be against TAM (doubtful) or UGA (more likely) in the SEC title game. I think Alabama gets into the playoff with one loss, and ultimately loses in the playoff (either semi or title game) to a team with an elite offense, which it cannot outscore due to a not-explosive or not- highly efficient passing game. The Tide finishes 12-2 or 13-2. They make the playoff, possibly win the SEC title, but do not win the national title.
If it doesn't work out this year, fear not: 2022 will be one of Saban's all-time best teams.