Thursday, September 24, 2020

2020 Alabama Football Report



For nearly all Americans, 2020 has constituted the worst year one can ever remember. A once-in-a-lifetime global pandemic, economic collapse, persistent protests, hurricanes, the West ablaze, and….an earthquake in North Carolina??? If it can go wrong, it has gone wrong.


If you’re an Alabama fan, reading the phrase, “if it can go wrong, it will go wrong,” might trigger your experience of the 2019 football season. The 2019 edition of Alabama football was, in effect, a “2020” type season in football terms, if that makes sense.


Alabama rolled into the 2019 campaign with what some people considered the most talented team in Saban’s era. Only a couple of things that could derail the season: losing Tua and losing both middle linebackers. Otherwise, it looked like a slam dunk to win the SEC and end up in the playoff. Like clockwork, both middle linebackers were out for the season before the first game. Two starting defensive linemen were injured along the way. Tua suffered a nearly catastrophic injury two weeks before the Iron Bowl. To add insult to injury, Alabama lost a typical Jordan-Hare Iron Bowl with bizarre plays, bad breaks, and calls so questionable that, once again, led to rules changes. This is all you need to know about Alabama’s season: opponents did not miss a single field goal against the Tide all year; they went 100%. A freak season of improbable outliers ended with Alabama’s first regular season with more than one loss in nine years. 


With the actual 2020 football campaign upon us, I have some good news. I do not think Alabama has one of the greatest teams of the Saban era this season, but it does have one of the most complete teams the Tide has fielded in the last five years. Furthermore, in this bizarre, unstable climate, I do think Alabama is one of the best situated teams for making it to the national title game. 


This Report

This is the 20th anniversary of this little report. It started with a long, long email to a friend who asked in 2000, “How do you think the season is going to go?” The email list grew and then I put it on a little blog. I know nothing about the x’s and o’s of football. I just listen to and read tons of information about Alabama football, and I have far more expensive, liberal arts education than any man should have. 


Why Alabama Is Uniquely Positioned to Capitalize on the Chaos of the 2020 Season
Before I get into the analysis of the offense, defense, and schedule, I want to begin with the advantages the Tide has coming into this year. 


(1) Continuity and Experience

Alabama returns four offensive linemen, a QB with starting experience, and four other returning starters on offense. They return two corners, two DLs, two MLBs, and a safety with starting experience. They return all but one position coach and both coordinators. During a year without spring practice and limited summer preparation, very experienced teams have a massive advantage. Inexperienced teams like LSU will be hurt by this. 


(2) Alabama is a non-emotional program.

Saban’s teams are somewhat pejoratively referred to as robotic, meaning they are not an emotionally-driven program. Teams like Auburn and LSU get lots of juice and motivation from the home-crowd, but there’s little juice to be cleaned from a stadium that is 75% empty. This will help Alabama’s robotic, methodical mentality. For example, playing in a near empty Tiger Stadium gives the Tide a major advantage, while Alabama will not lose much by hosting Georgia and Auburn without much crowd noise. Alabama will be a great “empty stadium” team. 


(3) Saban’s process orientation

Saban’s process is predicated on blocking out external factors and focusing on what you can control. In a year with tons of distractions, I get the sense that the Tide has been all-business and singularly focused since March. They seem to have taken advantage of the lockdown with incessant film study and appear to have remotely maintained a solid strength and conditioning program. While others seem to have struggled adjusting, Alabama appears to have thrived, according to insiders. 


(4) Pretty much the whole team has had Covid already
It’s a poorly kept secret that a vast majority of the team either came back to campus having had Covid or got it this summer. We probably won’t have too many guys miss games because….. most of them have the antibodies already. 


2020 in a Sentence

An experienced, complete Alabama team, which is well-suited for this bizarre season, wins the SEC and makes it to the national title game. 



The Offense

Alabama will field an excellent offense in 2020 behind a strong offensive line, a good quarterback, and elite skills players. 


Quarterback
Mac Jones is far better than I ever gave him credit for. Jones played extraordinarily well in his four starts. His QB Rating was 91.1, which would have placed him third in all of college football last year if he had a few more snaps, and makes him the most efficient returning QB in the SEC. (Second is Kyle Trask with 81.3. Highly regarded Bo Nix had a 63.8 QBR.) Given that Alabama will have a great OL, a strong ground game, and two elite receivers, Mac Jones is poised to have a great year. He can manage a game well but also has play-making ability with his arm. He’s not sexy but does have a little “poor man’s Joe Burrow” potential with his quick release, accuracy, and moxie, but he’s probably far more turnover prone. Bryce Young has elite skills and is the star of the future, but with the disrupted schedule, I expect Mac to start from beginning to end. 


Grade: A-….. Good / Very Good
Mac Jones is not elite, but he could put up very impressive numbers with all of the offensive assets around him. I think Mac will be surprisingly impressive. (I just can’t get his production against Auburn and Michigan, the two best defenses the Tide played, out of my head. Bryce Young is a luxury to have as a back up.)



Running Back

Expect Najee Harris to be a bell-cow who gets 20+ carries per game in an SEC-only schedule. Najee has averaged an impressive 6.1 ypc in his career. He had 7 TDs receiving last year and over 300 yards in the air, to go along with 1,200+ and 13 TDs on the ground. As the featured back for Alabama, Najee has a good chance to get invited to New York for the Heisman. Brian Robinson is fine, but I expect Tre Sanders to pass him and get more of the second-string carries by mid-season. Roydell Williams has been impressive in fall camp, from inside reports. 


Grade: A….Very Good 247 rates Alabama as having the #1 RB group in college football. I tend to agree. The offensive line and the threat of big play receivers likely enables Alabama’s running game to be the strength of the team. 



Receivers

When it’s all said and done, Alabama’s 2019 group will probably have at least three, if not four, first rounders. It’s astonishing. The 2020 group still likely has two with Jaylen Waddle and Devonta Smith. Waddle will move out of the slot to the outside, and many NFL Mock Drafts have him as the #2WR for next year’s draft. Devonta Smith is the most productive returning WR in the SEC with over 1,200 yards and 14 TDs last year. John Metchie appears to be a competent third receiver with really good hands. Don’t sleep on the Slade Cat (Slade Bolden) who has drawn positive reviews as a slot receiver. Much buzz has come out about the tall true freshman, Javon Baker, who has turned a lot of heads during the fall. 


Grade:  A…. Very Good  247 ranks this the second best group of receivers in the country. They are arguably the best, given that there are two probable first rounders in the group. The running game and O-line should make this group explosive again. 



Tight Ends

This is the weakest area on the offense. Transfer Carl Tucker sounds like a relatively solid blocker. Miller Forstall has experience and is an above average receiver, probably an average blocker. Jahleel Billingsley has lined up at receiver some, but I would not expect to see him with a hand down. Cameron Latu has made surprisingly good progress and appears to have promise for next year. Alabama needs this group to be “not bad,” and I think they probably have enough to basically meet that standard. 


Grade: B-…..Average An average group that has enough experience and ability to build on last year, when they were a borderline liability at times.



Offensive Line

Veteran Alabama fans are tired of hearing that this will be the “best offensive line since 2012.” That group is the touchstone for greatness in Alabama lore, and I think the 2020 group could generate similar results this season. LT Leatherwood is in his third year as a starter, and he played quite a bit in his first year. Basically every mock draft projects that he’ll be taken in the first twenty picks. Evan Neal has moved out to RT, where he reportedly has done well. He projects to be taken in the first 10 in the 2022 Draft. After being tried at guard, Landon Dickerson will end up at center, where Sports Illustrated considers him the #3 center prospect in the 2021 Draft. Dickerson was voted to the coaches’s First Team All SEC Team. (Starting to get the picture?) After being put on notice for suspect pass protection, Deonte “Cornbread” Brown has won the left guard position and will start for his second year. (Cornbread started a fair amount three years ago as well.) Emil Ekiyor, a mammoth offensive guard (6’3, 340), whom the coaches have been high on for two years, has won the left guard position. Phil Steele did not publish an “offensive line experience chart” this year as he normally does, but this group would likely fit in the Top 40 if he did. 


Alabama has good depth on the OL. Darrian Dalcourt is smart, quick, and good, but still needs to add weight. Pierce Quick has drawn strong reviews and could come in at tackle or guard. Chris Owens is a serviceable player with some starts under his belt, but he’s not quite powerful enough to start. He still provides nice depth. 


Grade: A+….Great This is likely the best offensive line group in the country. 247 ranks it at #2 behind Notre Dame, which is kind of a joke. There’s lots of talent, size, and experience. 



Overall Offensive Grade:  A….Very Good I think the group compares favorably to the 2012 offense. Then, Alabama had a great offensive line with a talented backfield and, thereby, a dominant running game. AJ McCarron was a very good QB and Amari Cooper was an electric freshman. This 2020 offensive line is great. Mac Jones has a lower ceiling than AJ, but he’s probably a better game manager. He could easily be considered a “poor man’s AJ” and get equal to better results, because Mac has significantly better receivers. I think Alabama will be able to run effectively on just about everyone on the schedule (maybe even UGA), and this should open up the vertical passing game for Waddle and Smith. Given that Mac has a pretty good deep ball, I believe that the Alabama passing attack will be able to exploit the advantage that the running game provides. This offense will be different than what we were accustomed to with Tua, where the Tide struck quick and put up absurd scoring numbers. I believe the Tide will possess the ball longer and be more methodical than in the past several years, which should help the defense. Altogether, I think Alabama has the best offense in the conference and one of the top 5 in the country. 



The Defense


Last year’s defense was the second worst of the Saban era. The group finished 37th in the country in rush defense and 20th in total defense. That’s not catastrophic, but also not what Alabama fans are used to. I already have documented the rash of inopportune injuries. 


Another element of last year’s struggles involved the defensive coordinator. From accounts, Golding seems to be very, very bright and grasps Saban’s defensive philosophy well. It seems that he struggled in simplifying the system into terms that the players—especially the true freshmen starting out of necessity—could understand. So much of the defensive performance this year depends on his ability communicate with the defense in playcalling, a task Charlie Strong has been called on to tutor him in. 


Defensive Line

This group, which was relatively young, showed very little improvement over the course of last year. This year, they could be anywhere from mediocre to quite good; so much depends upon players playing into their potential. LaBryan Ray, a former five-star, showed promise last year before his injury. DJ Dale, who was the star of last year’s mammoth DL class, was having a very good year until he got banged up. Christian Barmore has ridiculous upside; most mock drafts rate him as a 1st round pick in the NFL Draft (of which I am dubious). Barmore is the best playmaker on the DL and has a knack for tackles for loss, but he’s also unreliable on assignments and can be a liability for big plays. Depth behind these guys is good, making for a nice rotation. At the same time, I think the success of the DL depends on the first three staying healthy and living up to their potential. 


Grade: B+…Good with upside The lack of proven stars with sustained success makes me hesitant to call this group great or very good, but the potential is there. 247 rates this the 3rd best DL group in the country. 



Middle Linebackers

Dylan Moses may be the best MLB in the country. A number of programs have him as a preseason All-American and nearly all mock drafts have him taken in the first round. Alongside Moses, I think Christian Harris will be a star. Given that he had never played a snap at LB before he started every game of last year, he did quite well and improved as the season progressed. I think this is the best inside LB group in the country. Depth behind them is good as well. Neither Josh McMillon, Jalen Moody, nor Shane Lee is above average athletically, but they’ve played lots of football and know what they are doing. 


Grade: A…. Very Good Harris and Moses together could be something special to see. I think this group is the strength of Alabama defense. 



Outside Linebacker
Will Anderson has been the star of the fall, regardless of position. Sources say he’s racked up multiple sacks in scrimmages, and he will start at Jack. One issue, though, is that many people have cautioned the Anderson and Drew Sanders, another true freshman and rising star, both struggle to stand up against the run. As it stands, Anderson appears to be the best pass rusher on the team. Sanders has also drawn strong reviews and projects to be a star down the road. (Joey Bosa comparisons have been made. Wow.)


Chris Allen appears to be the starter at Sam LB with Ben Davis backing him up. Neither of these guys are playmakers but could be competent in setting the edge and standing up against the run. (Think Denzell Deval.) I think they’ll both be off the field in obvious passing situations. (Dylan Moses has been reported to come down to the edge in passing situations.)


Grade: B-…..Above Average with Upside This group has the most upside on the team. As the season progresses, if Sanders and Anderson grow against the run, the OLBs could bump up to a good or very good group. As of now, Allen and Davis have a pretty set, modest ceiling. Anderson is a star but could be a little bit of a liability against the run at this point. I would bank on them making lots of progress. 



Corners

Most mock drafts rate Patrick Surtain as a first round pick, and he’s either a first or second team All-American on most preseason teams. I think Surtain is very good but I also think he has something to prove this year after a few bumps last season. Fortunately, this is a contract year, and I expect him to play well. Josh Jobe has struggled with maturity issues but played relatively well in the latter part of last year. Marcus Banks has reportedly had a strong fall and will be the first corner off the bench. 


Grade: A-….Very Good  This is a strong group with the potential to have a great season. Both Surtain and Jobe need to take a step forward for this to occur. 



Safeties

Alabama has much to replace in the back three. Jordan Battle played quite a bit last year and has tons of talent. I don’t think Battle is in the same category as players like Mark Barron and Landon Collins, but he’s still a solid player. Daniel Wright is very talented and set to start, but he’s reported to have maturity issues that have plagued him during his three years in Tuscaloosa. Brian Branch is the new rising star in the back three and will likely start. He has great ball skills and athleticism. Malachi Moore, another true freshman, also has played a great deal and could start at Star. DeMarcco Hellams continues to draw strong reviews. It wouldn’t be surprising if he beat out Daniel Wright over the course of the season. 


Grade: B-…. Above Average This group has good talent but very little experience. Two true freshmen are manning the Star position. That’s a sign that they’re good but also a touch concerning about those around them. I think they’ll be the weakest part of the defense and will take some lumps during the year. 



Overall Defensive Grade: B+….Good There is a lot of potential on this group, but I think we have to accept two realities. First, we only have two truly proven, consistent, outstanding players in Surtain and Moses. I think many others could take the step forward (Barmore, Harris, Jobe, Battle, Ray, Dale, Wright, and Anderson), but they have to prove that on the field. Secondly, the defense looked discombobulated and out of sorts for much of last year. They had games where they looked totally incompetent, like Auburn and LSU, and Golding was the nexus of this. Golding certainly has the intelligence to make this work, but can he learn to communicate, particularly with play-calling? That is not proven yet either. I think this group will be “good enough,” but not likely to be a dominant group. I do think they have the potential to grow and improve as the season continues. 




The Schedule

Win or lose, the ten game all-SEC schedule will be a lot of fun. Here is how I see it breaking down this year. 


Relatively Easy Wins

Missouri - I think the Tigers made a very good hire in Eliah Drinkwitz, who has an impressive track record of success from Appalachian State. Unfortunately, the Tigers have a pretty pitiful roster. Alabama should win big. 


Ole Miss - I think Lane Kiffin will likely be an unmitigated disaster in Oxford. He inherited a bad roster and recruiting isn’t going terribly well right now either. Lane may sneak up and beat a good team this year because of his strength as a play-caller, but I think this game will get ugly in a hurry. 


Arkansas - The Razorbacks are averaging 2.6 wins per year over the last three seasons. Rough. Again, Alabama should win big in this one. 



Wins But Tougher Than You Would Expect


Tennessee - The Vols have one of the best OL’s in the country and have recruited nice talent on defense. I think Jeremy Pruett could have a solid year in the SEC East. Keep in mind that UT gave Alabama all they could handle after Tua went out. They caught some really bad breaks in what was a much closer game than the score indicated. I think the Vols will play Alabama tough, but Alabama still should prevail by double digits. 


Kentucky - The Wildcats are really well coached and have a great offensive line. They play solid defense too. They just have zero threat in the passing game. Don’t be surprised if Alabama struggles a bit against this team that will sneak up and beat someone good this year. Alabama still wins by double digits in a game that I think will be competitive into the third quarter. 


Mississippi State - Alabama should win this game comfortably but watch out for the Great Pirate. His passing game could trip up an inexperienced Alabama secondary and give them a long day. I expect lots of points in a relatively competitive game. 



Teams To Take Seriously But Ultimately Wins


Texas A&M- The Aggies are rated very highly in many preseason polls. They have good talent and an experienced (although pretty average) QB in Kellon Mond. TAM has recruited well and has a respectable roster. I think this will be the second toughest game on the schedule this year, but a game Alabama wins. I think Jimbo is very overrated and overpaid. While a tough game, I do think Alabama wins by more than a touchdown. 


LSU - I think LSU will likely be a four-loss team this year, at least. They’ve lost 34+ players off of last year’s roster, plus their DC and OC. They’ve made good hires but Brady and Aranda were absolutely great. You always take LSU seriously in Baton Rouge, even an empty Death Valley, but I think Alabama wins big and probably makes a deliberate effort to run up the score if possible. While these games in Baton Rouge are always tough, I think Alabama could beat the defending national champions by 20+. 


Auburn - I think this is going to be a down year for Auburn after losing so many quality players on the OL and DL from last year. Auburn will basically have four new starters on the OL. Auburn has also recruited very poorly over the past three years at OL, having signed a small number of players and none who were very highly recruited. If you track Malzahn’s career, he has bad years when the OL is inexperienced and poor. This is one of those years. Auburn’s losses on the DL are significant as well and may make them susceptible to getting abused by teams with very good running games. (Like Alabama.) Auburn has two very good coordinators in Steele and Morris. Still, I think their offense, despite having good skills players, will struggle quite a bit because of the OL. Let’s also not forget that, with Mac Jones at the helm, the Tigers allowed 45 points to Alabama last year. I’ve heard Saban would like to humiliate Gus this year. Barring some Covid or injury freak nightmare (which is always possible, if not the norm when playing Auburn), Alabama should win this game. I’m not sure Alabama can run up the score, but I do think Alabama will win, probably by double digits. 


Dogfight


UGA - Georgia has some real issues on offense. They have four new starters on the OL and an unproven QB situation. This is not a good recipe for offensive success. Their defense will be totally awesome, though, perhaps the best in the country. I think Alabama likely wins this game and benefits from playing the Dogs early in the season, but it will be tough as nails and close. 



Final Regular Season Record and SEC Championship Game: 


10-1



While I can’t really pick a specific game that Bama loses, I think there’s a loss in there somewhere. That's just the nature of 2020. My guess is UGA is the most likely culprit with Tennessee or Texas A&M being the other big threats. During this weird Covid season, I think going 11-0 is highly improbable. 


How It Ends

I think Alabama has the most complete team in the country. Along with Clemson, they probably have the best overall offense with a very strong running game, a solid QB, and two explosive receivers. I think their ability to control the ball and sustain drives will help the defense. The defense could end up being very good but, for now, there are lots of contingencies (5-6 players stepping up, Golding demonstrating competence that we haven’t seen yet.) 


One unmentioned factor is Alabama’s kicking game. For the first time in a while, I think the Tide has a “not terrible” place kicker. The punter seems adequate. Waddle is a first team All-American in most publications for return specialist. 


I think the Tide drops a game in SEC play. Given how close the UGA games have been and how good the Dog defense will be this year, I have a hard time seeing the Tide beating UGA twice, if they happen to face them both in the regular season and the title game. At the same time, Florida will be very good and UGA may not end up in the SEC Title game at all.


I think Alabama makes it to the SEC Title game and wins the SEC, picking up one loss along the way. They will advance to the playoff and likely face Clemson in the national championship game. I think Clemson and Alabama are pretty evenly matched with Clemson, perhaps, having a slight edge. At the end of the day, I like the Tide to win the game and win the national championship for three reasons. 


First, as I’ve stated before, the Covid chaos immensely favors Alabama’s mentality and experience. 


Secondly, Scott Cochran lives more than 250 miles away from Tuscaloosa. Cochran did a great job at Alabama and deserves a great deal of credit for the Tide’s success. At the same time, the arrival of the new strength and conditioning coaches seems to have been a huge boost for the Tide. I think we were all accustomed to having lost multiple players for the season at this point over the last three years but, for now, the injury prevention program appears to be working. Let’s keep our fingers crossed. 


Finally, as pagan and unscientific as this may be, it’s time for the Tide to get lucky. Alabama has caught awful breaks over the last three years. Last year, I cannot remember an Alabama team having worse luck at every level. Meanwhile, Clemson hasn’t caught a bad break since the 2016 national title game, until Justyn Ross was lost for this present season. Banking on the laws of probability, I think the Tide will have a very, very good team and will catch some breaks along the way to win the national title. 


Final Outcome: Alabama wins the national title with a 12-1 record.