Sunday, August 26, 2018

2018 Alabama Prognostication

2018 ALABAMA PROGNOSTICATION

It’s time for football season. The following is my annual little prognostication. It started as an email to one friend in 2000. The people on the email grew over time. I put it on a blog in 2007, and here we are today, still kickin' it on Blogger, the most archaic platform in the world.

Times are high in Tuscaloosa. Alabama’s average regular season record in the last ten years is 11.1 and 0.9. Yes that’s less than one loss per season. In total Alabama has averaged 12.6 wins per season. Wow! Alabama has won five national titles in nine years. It’s the greatest run in college football history.

As we begin to consider the 2018, one question is worth posing: is Alabama’s preseason perception for what constitutes a championship caliber team utterly skewed? Thru Bama glasses the  2017 title team was not a great team. Below average QB. Pretty good OL. Good but not 2016 caliber DL. Great secondary but started a walk on and three-star at corner. Plus suffered catastrophic injuries. And yet, 14-1 national champions while playing six true freshmen in the second half and OT of national title game. The 2017 team was probably Saban’s 6th best team at Alabama (I’d put 2016 above 2017) but they won the national title.

As I look at Alabama’s 2018 I see a great offense but not a championship caliber defense. Then again, am I comparing the defense to the 2009, 2011, 2015, and 2016 squads? Because it’s not a dominant, #1 national  defense am I assuming it’s just average? It’s hard to tell. Here’s 2018 in a paragraph.

2018 IN A PARAGRAPH
Alabama will field it’s best offense of my lifetime. However, a very inexperienced secondary and already maligned linebacking corps hinder this team from being a clear cut national championship lock. An easy schedule will help the cause. Will the Tide pull it out?

PAST SEASON TO COMPARE TO
This season resembles 2012. A talented returning QB situation, excellent OL, and great RBs. Defense is not as dominant as usual. Schedule is super easy in the first 2/3’s of the season. Last four games are brutal. This season could play out in a similar fashion to 2012.

QUALIFIER
I don’t know anything about football. I just listen, talk, and read a lot and I have an overpriced liberal arts education.

ALABAMA OFFENSE
Looking at the position groups, I cannot remember a more talented offense in my lifetime. The crown jewel is the elite QB that Alabama never has seemed to be able to secure. It’s going to be an incredibly fun offense to watch.

QUARTERBACK
l do not think there is much of a battle at QB. Jalen Hurts seems to have taken a step back in his confidence and as a passer. He still struggles to do a route progression and to be consistently accurate. Meanwhile Tua has been extremely impressive throughout fall camp. I think Tua will start but Jalen will get meaningful snaps throughout the first three games. It would not stun me if Saban still gave Jalen the nod to start for the first 1-3 games to keep him around. However, I think Tua starts Texas A&M. After Alabama plays TAM, I think (total opinion) Jalen will morph into a specialty, situational role. Tua is the best QB of my lifetime (since ‘85) at Alabama. He’s accurate, has great vision, and has the major It factor. Unless Saban limits Tua’s snaps trying to keep Jalen happy and engaged, I think Tua will be invited to NYC for the Heisman ceremony.

Grade: A+  Your starter is a Heisman candidate (#1 in Vegas) and your back up is competent enough to get two teams to the national title game. Best situation in America.

RUNNING BACK
Alabama has had some legendary RB groups; this one fits into that category. Damien Harris returns as one of the top backs in America. Najee Harris was the #1 RB in America coming out of high school in 2017 and flashed greatness. He’s injured so don’t be surprised if he is limited in the first 2-3 games. Josh Jacobs is healthy and apparently looked good in both scrimmages. I think Brian Robinson will be a Heisman finalist in 2020. He’s awesome.

Grade:  A+  A truly elite group.

WIDE RECEIVER
This is the best and most fun WR group of my lifetime at Bama. Riggs, Jeudy, and Smith are all electric, have great hands, and run good routes. They’re very skilled. However, Alabama’s best weapon may be Jaylen Waddle, a true freshman from TX who has wowed people in fall practice. Waddle may be a more slippery version of Calvin Ridley. He likely will return punts. Terrell Shavers, who is 6’6 and runs well, is an intriguing weapon. Even Derrick Kief has made plays. What makes this group so exciting and unique is they actually have a QB who can get the ball to them. They have a QB who can get the ball to the tertiary receiver or throw a precise jump ball to take advantage of a huge receiver. (Oh to have one more year for Cam Sims.) There’s not an obvious go-to star like Julio or Amari but because the QB is so good, all of the very good receivers will get utilized.

Grade: A+  Great  I think this is the best overall group I can remember at Alabama in my lifetime. There are a couple of groups in the country that are better with their top 3 starters (Ole Miss being one) but I think this is one of the better group from 1-6.

OFFENSIVE LINE
Alabama ranks #13 in the nation in returning career starts on O-Line. That’s a big deal. The Tide has three returning starters. Jonah Williams likely will be taken in the first round and Piersbacher is a four year starter. The two new additions - second year players Wills and Leatherwood - were both five-star prospects. Lester Cotton will start for his third year. The coaches say he's the guy you want to run behind if you need one yard. Total mauler. I think this will be the second best run blocking group of the Saban era (behind 2012). They should be good enough in pass blocking. Leatherwood and Wills have switched with Leatherwood at RG now and Wills at RT. Leatherwood has been relatively unreliable - his spring was abysmal - but his ceiling is the highest on the team at OL. Given that Alabama will not be tested in their first eight games, they can afford to gamble a bit and let him learn on the job. Depth is very good.

Grade: A  Very good. This is probably the best OL group Alabama has had under Saban other than 2012. They will be beastly in the run game and good enough in pass blocking.

TIGHT END
A very knowledgeable friend pointed out to me that tight end is perhaps the best position group on the team. This caught me off guard. However, when you look at this group, it is perhaps the deepest on the squad. Alabama returns three players who catch the ball well in Miller Forestall, Irv Smith, and Kedrick James. Hentges is a very good blocker and Major Tennison would start at a lot of SEC schools. James is the unheralded star to watch out for. He is a load and runs well. A good athlete with good hands. He’s still probably a year away but one to watch out for. Dan Enos, our QB coach who will have influence over the offense, loves to use the tight end. I think they will be a factor.

Grade: A  Very Good- This group most importantly will aid the run game but there are some receivers here who will benefit the passing game more than most expect.

ANALYSIS OF THE OFFENSE
I think this will be Saban’s best overall offense at Alabama. It compares favorably to 2012, however, I think Tua may be a touch better than AJ (who I think is the best Alabama QB of my lifetime) and the receiver situation is more established and deeper. I think this will be a good balanced attack. Damein Harris and Najee Harris (who hopefully will recover from a nagging fall-camp injury) should both have big seasons. As crazy as this sounds, I expect that Tide to put up 45.0+ points per game in the regular season. If nothing else it will be a great deal of fun.


DEFENSE
Due to major losses in the secondary and some significant injuries at linebacker (yet again), I come into this season a bit nervous about the usually dominant Alabama defense. Keep in mind, the standard is absurd. I found myself talking about how our defense was not the typically dominant dense last year and was reminded that Alabama finished #1 in the nation in total defense. A top 20 defense feels like a failure in Tuscaloosa. Here’s a look at the position groups.

DEFENSIVE LINE
The best position group on the defense. Alabama continues to develop defensive linemen well and that only will get better with the hiring of Craig Kuligowski, who is generally considered the best DL coach in college football. All NFL mock drafts project Raekwon Davis to be in the first 15 picks of the first round next spring. Isaiah Buggs is strong and NFL Draft Scout rates him the #5 DE in his draft class. Quinnen Williams is quietly a rising star. He was very effective when he played last year and has had a great offseason. He will have a break out year. With this front three, Alabama has a unique situation of guys who can play the run but also rush the passer. There is not a Terrence Cody situation where a different set of personnel must be brought in on third downs. Highly-rated 2017 freshmen, LaBryan Ray and Phi Mathis, have both developed well. They will play a significant role. True freshman Stephon Wynn enrolled in January and is highly thought of. Christian Barrymore has a high ceiling but sounds like he has a way to go before he is ready to contribute. Johnny Dwight can play some snaps.

Grade: A  Very Good. Lots of experience. Good potential to generate an interior pass rush. Very good against the run. Surprising depth. I think this group will be instrumental in the Tide’s success.


LINEBACKER
The Alabama Linebacker Curse continues. This went from being the top LB position group in the country to an area of concern for Alabama, due to the loss of Terrell Lewis and Chris Allen and a unusually thin linebacker haul in the 2018 recruiting class. The first group is still outstanding but the depth is tenuous.

Mack Wilson and Dillon Moses are the best pair of inside linebackers in the conference. They should be exciting to watch. Still, both incurred injuries during last season. The back up situation is not terribly inspiring with the dismissal of Vondarious Cowan. Markail Benton has made progress and is good in pass coverage. Unheralded recruit Jaylen Moody has been better than his two star billing would suggest and Josh McMillon has been in the system a long time. While much hype surrounded the late arrival and transfer of highly rated ILB Ale Kaho, his lean frame and late arrival will likely prevent him from being a viable depth option until late in the season, if at all. While the depth in the inside is not as dire as initially expected, you still don’t want any of the back ups starting with the exception of Benton.

Outside linebacker was the most dominant position on the team. With the loss of Terrell Lewis and Chris Allen it now becomes a liability. Anfernee Jennings is considered the #2 OLB in his draft class. He’s projected in the top 35 in most mock drafts. He could be great this year. Christian Miller is also an experienced stud who has a knack for rushing the passer. Jamey Mosely can provide some depth. Juarez Parks entered in January as a greyshirt (the famous top 100 player who had to greyshirt to be in the 2017 class). He is first off the bench right now. Eyobi Anoma is a great pass rusher. He was the #1 rated defensive player in the country coming out of high school. He’s still young and a little thin. He likely will play more situationaly for now in obvious pass rushing situations. Sadly Ben Davis does not seem to be anywhere close to a reliable contributor. Again, if either Miller or Jennings go down, this group quickly goes from being an asset to an area of concern. 

Grade: A- Good with downside - This group is one starter injury away from turning from excellent to an Achilles heel. It would be helpful if Parks, Anoma, or Kaho can progress rapidly.

SECONDARY
The area of greatest concern on the team is the secondary. This anxiety is with merit given that Alabama lost its top six players in this group. Harrison, Fitzpatrick, Hootie, Crazy Tony, Averette, and Wallace all are gone.

I think the safeties will actually be very good. Deonte Thompson flashed stardom in the playoff and is already considered a 2nd team preseason All SEC pick. Xavier McKinney is a rising star. He got a lot of snaps last year in mop up duty and I think is ready to break out. He's considered the top player in the secondary right now. Shayeim Carter likely plays the nickel position and will be good. The coaches seem to have high confidence in him. Jared Mayden provides good depth at safety. Patrick Surtain, the #1 CB recruit from last year’s class, has mainly played nickel with the first group but I have heard that it hasn’t gone well at this point. While there shall be growing pains and some busted coverages, but by the end of the year I think the safeties will be very good. 

Corners make me a little more nervous. There appears to be plenty of talent led by five-star transfer Savion Smith. Word is that Trevon Diggs has improved a great deal. Josh Jobe has drawn rave reviews from a talent standpoint,  although he still has a long way to go at this point. While I could be wrong, I can see this group taking lots of lumps over this season. Like safeties there are no returning starters but most of the safeties have been on campus and in the program from 2-3 years. With corners, Diggs is the only person to have been on campus for more than nine months. Jobe and Surtain are brand new. Given the complexity of the Alabama secondary and how much pressure Saban’s system inherently puts on the corners, I think this group could have some big issues against teams with good QBs and talented receivers, like Louisville, Missouri, Auburn, and UGA.

Grade: B with upside - I think the safeties will be fine. I think the corners will take their lumps early but hopefully can grow. The group is very, very talented.

OVERALL DEFENSIVE ANALYSIS
Saban’s system is built with this mentality. Take away the running game. Take away easy passes in the flat with lots man, press coverage in the flats. The point of vulnerability is in the vertical passing game. If you want to score on Alabama you’re going to have to have a QB who can beat elite defensive backs vertically. Very, very few QBs can do this at the college level. Usually Alabama has both elite CBs and a wicked pass rush that make scoring on the Tide nearly impossible. Hence the seemingly perennial #1 rated defenses.

If Terrell Lewis has not gotten injured, I would have told you that this group would be great again. Lewis may be the best overall football player in college. Our coaches considered him our overall very best player. His absence significantly changes my outlook.

Another factor is the presence of a new defensive coordinator, Tosh Lupoi, who has never called plays. Pete Golding, who has an impressive track record as a DC, will be involved to a varying level, and may fill in where Tosh has weaknesses. Still, this is a change to not overlook. 

I think we will play the run very well with our front seven. I think our ability to rush the passer without blitzing will be compromised, putting more pressure on an already young, inexperienced secondary. As a result I think there will be four-ish games (namely Louisville, Missouri, Auburn, Ole Miss, or MSU) where strong passing teams with a respectable running presence will score in the 20’s, which will make Alabama fans very uncomfortable. Furthermore, the linebackers are very thin. The depth issues there mean that the stretch of the last 4-5 games (if you include the SECCG) will be against brutally physical teams (LSU, MSU, AU, and UGA). Alabama lost to Auburn last year largely because they were beleaguered from injuries and physical games.  Auburn’s physical line was able to generate a run game.

A best case scenario will be that the young LBs develop fast and provide needed depth while the secondary exceeds my expectations. In particular, Anoma becomes a surprise spark in the pass rush, Parks becomes a contributor, and either Moody or Kaho emerge as an unexpected stud. If Savion and Diggs turn out to be surprisingly good, then this could be a really good defense. I do not see the ideal situation occurring.

OVERALL DEFENSIVE GRADE: B+   I think the secondary will give up points and yardage in a few games and that depth issues will catch up with the Tide in the last third of the season.


THE SCHEDULE
Alabama has one of the easiest schedules in memory. Their two hardest games are at home. Their East opponent is Missouri. Louisville is good but not a real threat to beat the Tide. All of the difficult games are on the back end of the schedule.


Louisville
Bobby Petrino is one of the great playcallers in college football. Louisville will keep the Tide off balanced for most of the day. I expect the Cardinals to put up 20-28 points, which will make Alabama fans very antsy. They’ve got a new but good QB, Jawon Pass. The good news: I think Alabama will score 40-50 points in this game, generated mostly from the running game. Their defense ranked 84th in the country last year.

Arkansas State
Arkansas St is the decisive pick to win the Sun Belt. They’re a good team that could slip up on just about any SEC team, but not Alabama, in my opinion. They’ll be competitive but I like Alabama to win by 30 due to a significant talent advantage.

Ole Miss
Barrett Sallee picked Ole Miss to beat Alabama. [Insert emoji for mindless facial expression.] Ole Miss will score points. Their receivers are ridiculous and their QB is quietly pretty good. But I’m not particularly impressed with their head coach. I say "bless his heart' about every time I see him on TV. That's not a good sign. They’ll give up a ton of points. I think the Rebs score in the teens, maybe the 20’s, but again, I like Alabama to put up more than 40 in this game and to win by 3-4 TDs.

Texas A&M

Jimbo Fisher seems to bring a new legitimacy to Aggie Nation. I’m not sure that he has the tools he needs at this point, though, to string together a great season. I think this will be a tough game that Alabama wins. I think Tua establishes himself as the starter in this game. Again, I think Alabama puts up a lot of yards and points on a team that my dear ole Wake Forest ran through like Montezuma’s Revenge last year in the Belk Bowl (55 points). I think the Aggies keep it close in the first half and Alabama pulls away rapidly in the second half.

ULALA
It will be fun to say that we play “U-La-La” for a week. That just sounds nice off the tongue. But nothing will be fun about this game for the Ragin’ Cajuns. The Tide likely plays lots of freshmen due to the new redshirt rule.

Arkansas
I think this game will be ugly. Chad Morris is a worthwhile risk for the Hogs but his players don’t fit his system particularly well at this point. They also don’t have much to make a prolific offensive nervous. I think Alabama wins big in this one. Tide scores 45-55 and the Pigs in single digits or low teens.

Missouri

An intriguing game. Maty Mauk is one of the best QB’s in the country and considered a first round pick. Missouri can straight score. There is a kink in the plans. Missouri made a colossally bad OC hire in bringing on Derek Dooley, who makes sense in no way. I think Missouri scores in the mid-teens to low 20’s and Alabama gets 45+. Alabama may not punt but a handful of times in this game.

Tennessee
Jeremy Pruitt could work out in time but he has inherited a mess. It would surprise me if the Vols won more than one conference game this year. I think Alabama wins big and makes an earnest effort not to run up the score.

LSU

As I said from the beginning, Ogeron was a dreadful hire. I think LSU will fall to lows that they haven’t experienced since before Saban was in Baton Rouge. They just made a dreadful OC hire as well and continue to struggle to find an elite QB. I think this game will be physical as usual but Alabama will win in a fashion similar to last season: ugly but comfortable.

Mississippi State
State is going to be a good team. I like them to win ten games this year. They have a really good front seven and return 15-16 starters (depending on how you slice it). Nick Fitzgerald is a tricky QB to defend. I think this will be a tough, tough game reminiscent of 2014, but I think home field goes a long, long way. State tends to play pretty poorly in Tuscaloosa. I think Alabama’s defense will be peaking at this point before the attrition kicks in.

Citadel
Great game to take small kids to. Nice weather. Don’t have to watch. But this will be a massacre.

Auburn
Auburn should have a good team again this year, and they seem to play their best game of the year against the Tide annually. I think Alabama wins this game close for a few reasons. Auburn is ranked #114 in returning career starts on OL. AU develops OL well, but their lack of experience will be a formidable challenge to overcome and I think will chip into Stidham’s productivity against teams with a good inside pass rush. Stidham is really, really good and their receivers are excellent, but the OL issue I think will be a big one. Second, Gus still has not beaten Alabama, UGA, or LSU on the road in his five years as the Auburn coach: 0-7. Nothing leads me to believe his dismal road record will change this year with away games v. UGA and Bama on the docket. Finally, I don’t think Auburn matches up well with Alabama defensively. While AU has a first rate DL, their back seven is above average to good, but I wouldn’t call it very good or great. I think Tua will be able to exploit their weaknesses in this area. It will be a very tough and competitive game, but I think Alabama will win it.

HOW’S THE SEASON GOING TO END….


I will now write three ways I can see this season going, with one being the way I actually think it will play out.

Best Case Scenario
Tua plays at a Heisman level. (He is #1 in Las Vegas to win this award so it’s plausible.) The offensive line lives up to its billing and is a very good run blocking and good pass blocking group. The defense loses no more linebackers to significant injuries. Two LBs emerge as reliable contributors (Anoma, Parks, and Kaho most likely, but Mosely not out of the question). The corners, Savion and Diggs, progress and become reliable — not All-American but good — players. The defensive line consistently generates an inside pass rush — nothing all-time but good to very good. Terrell Lewis comes back for the playoffs and is effective in those two games. 

If the season goes this way, and all of this is feasible (except no LB injuries because we are cursed), then Alabama goes 15-0 and wins it all.

Worst Case Scenario
Alabama loses more linebackers. The corners show their youth more than their talent. Saban hangs on to Jalen too long and Tua never establishes a rhythm. Locksley and Tosh are both busts.

If all of these things happen, I think Alabama goes 10-2 or 11-1. The schedule is just so, so easy. The Tide does not make the playoff in this case. Even in “bad years,” Bama is so, so, so hard to beat. It takes the Tide having a dreadful day and the other team having a great day while catching insane breaks.

What I Think Will Happen

I think Alabama will go 12-0 in the regular season. Because of depth issues and a brutal stretch of LSU, MSU, and AU, I think the defense will limp into the SEC Title Game against UGA. UGA has a very good O-Line, a big-time QB in Fromm, home field advantage in ATL, and the revenge factor. I think they will beat Alabama in the SECCG.

If Alabama makes the playoff, which is probably 50/50, then I think they will be lose to Clemson. Alabama ultimately loses two games and fails to win the national title. I think they win the West and the Iron Bowl.

The best case scenario is totally possible. Don’t discount the possibility that Terrell Lewis could return for the playoff in a Superman manner like last year. The offense could carry Alabama to a title. I think this team is going to be insanely fun to watch because of the offense, but I do not think an SEC or national title is in the cards.







No comments:

Post a Comment