Friday, September 2, 2022

2022 Alabama Football Report

A friend of mine and I tend to have different perspectives on Alabama football. Most years during the Saban era, I have thought Alabama would lose 0-1 games in the regular season. My friend tends to expect 2 losses. 

Here are some stats and probabilities to give you a sense of just how successful Nick Saban has been. In the last fourteen years, Alabama has lost more than one regular season game only twice (2010 and 2019). This means that Alabama is six times more likely to lose one or fewer regular season games (12-0 or 11-1) than they are to lose two or more regular season games. To say that Alabama will lose two or more games is to bet that this is that one time in seven years that it occurs. 


Furthermore, in the last fourteen years, Alabama has played in the national title game nine out of fourteen times. This means that Alabama is more than twice as likely to play for the national title than not play. 


Given all of that success, remembering the six national titles that the Tide has gathered, here’s a shocking but honest statement: I think this may be the best Alabama team of the Saban era. After watching the scrimmage two weeks ago, I walked out of the stadium and said, “That’s the best I’ve ever seen an Alabama team look in August in my life.”  


Alabama likely has the most talented, experienced, and best defenses in the country. They return the Heisman Trophy winner at quarterback and promise to have one of the more explosive offenses in college football. The kicking game is actually good. Finally, this team has the best defensive player in America (Will Anderson) and the best offensive player in America (Bryce Young). 


Online publication 247 (https://247sports.com/Season/2022-Football/CollegeTeamTalentComposite/) has a metric for talent, based on recruiting evaluations. Regardless of how worthwhile this stat is, 247 says this team measures as the most talented team the publication has ever had in its rankings. But the team isn’t just talented. They have ample experience. Eight returning starters on defense. Three returning starters on the offensive line. Returning starter at tight end. Returning starter at QB and a RB who has started (McClellan). Three grad transfers who have started double-digit games at their respective schools (Steen, Gibbs, Burton). Plus, a three year starter at place kicker. 


There are some depth liabilities ; specifically, the Tide has some depth vulnerabilities at two critical positions. Still if Alabama can stay basically healthy at QB and offensive tackle, this Alabama team should win the national title: the question will be whether they go 15-0 or 14-1. 


Looking Back at Last Year’s Prediction 

Here was last year’s prediction. Not bad:

I think Scenario #2 is the outcome for the 2021 campaign. I think Alabama will have one game where they need to outscore an opponent and simply can’t and another game where the offense is really flat against a good opposing defense and they lose a close one. I think the former loss will be against an explosive team like Ole Miss (regular season) or Oklahoma in the playoff. The latter loss could be against TAM or UGA in the SEC title game. I think Alabama gets into the playoff with one loss, and ultimately loses in the playoff (either semi or title game) to a team with an elite offense, which it cannot outscore due to a not-explosive or highly efficient passing game. The Tide finishes 12-2 or 13-2. They make the playoff, possibly win the SEC title, but do not win the national title. 


Here was 2020. I missed on the record but got the ultimate outcome:


Final Outcome - Alabama wins the national title with a 12-1 record. (We went 13-0). 


Caveat

I don't know anything about the X’s and O’s of football. Just consume tons of information about the Tide. 


The Story

A friend emailed me in 2000 asking for my prediction on the upcoming season. I replied with a 4,000 word email. He liked it, and the next year asked me for the “long version” of my prediction again, but copied a bunch of friends on the email. The email grew over the years and I moved it to a blog in 2006. 


The 2022 Season in a Nutshell 

An elite Alabama team rolls to a national title behind an experienced defense and a very good (but not great) offense, unless Bryce Young or both offensive tackles get injured. 


The Offense

So much about the Alabama team depends upon the offensive line. Otherwise, this should be a very good but not elite group. 


Quarterback

Bryce Young is the returning Heisman winner. He’s looked great in the fall. Behind Bryce there are problems. Ty Simpson will be a star one day, but he’s not ready. Jalen Milroe may be the best athlete on the team, but he’s not an accurate or reliable passer. I do think Milroe could be used in short yardage to run the ball as he’s so so big and so fast. 


Grade: A +… Great - Bryce Young is the best QB in America. If he goes down, the season’s expectations shift pretty significantly due to the weakness of the back ups. 



Running Back

Jahmyr Gibbs is the talk of fall camp. He’s an elite transfer from GA Tech who is an explosive runner and very effective receiver. He projects to go in the first round of the draft. I expect him to be the feature back. Jas McClellan looked surprisingly strong in the fall scrimmage. Roydell did as well. Trey Sanders seems to be running fourth string and one has to wonder if Trey has lost a step from the two significant injuries he sustained. 


Grade: A…Very Good



Wide Receiver

There appears to be no “go-to” star in this group, however, there is a committee of weapons. Traeshon Holden looked very dangerous in the fall, catching 3 TDs in the second scrimmage. People may forget that he caught 6 passes in the national title game last year. Tremaine Burton from UGA looks very smooth and very reliable. Speedster Kobe Prentice had a great fall and has won the starting job vacated after JoJo Earl was injured. Ja’Corey Brooks had a disappointing fall. He certainly has great upside but he did not win a starting position. Shaz Preston and Kendrick Law are players to watch as the season progresses. 


I think Bryce Young has plenty of weapons at his disposal. I also wonder and question whether anyone will step forward as the “go-to” guy that will demand the defense’s constant attention. I do not think this is an elite group but I think they’ll be exciting to watch. 


Grade: B+ with upside….Good to Very Good - There is a lot of talent but the apparent absence of a star does cause one to question how high the ceiling is or isn’t for this team. 


Tight End
Cameron Latu returns as a starter and is rated as one of the top tight ends for the draft. He is not an elite star but is second team preseason All SEC. Robbie Outz appears to function more like an H-back and short yardage fullback. Not much more. Amari Niblack has looked good as a receiver but is way too small to block. Hopefully he can put on weight as he progresses. Danny Lewis was a surprisingly effective receiver at tight end and is a nice option for the future. 


Grade: B+…..Good - Nothing special but a really solid group. Latu could be a weapon if he can get consistent with his hands. 


Offensive Line

This offense could be great if the offensive line can be basically good. We do not need them to be elite, just good. I think the addition of offensive line coach Eric Wolford could be a difference-making factor in Alabama’s season. He’s a career offensive line coach, who has done well at a number of stops. 


Of note, transfer Tyler Steen seems to be reliable as a pass blocker but not overpowering as a run blocker. Center Darrian Dalcourt has massive upside, but here in his third year we are waiting to see if he can make the leap. Returns are positive on his progress under coach Eric Wolford. Javion Cohen likely will work his way back into the starting guard position within the first 2-4 games, but after missing six weeks at a mental health treatment facility, he’s not in football shape. I believe Cohen is our best offensive lineman. Ekiyor is starting for his third year and is a reliable fixture, who will have a nice career in the NFL. JC Latham was the top OL in the nation coming out of high school. He appears to be growing into his reputation at right tackle. In time, this starting five should grow into a good group. It could be a very good group if Dalcourt can have a break-out year. However, there is a glaring vulnerability that resides among the back ups at the tackle positions. Any of the options (Kite and George) would be a pretty large liability. Alabama needs JC Latham and Tyler Steen to remain healthy. 


Grade: B+ with upside…Above Average The OL was not good at all last year. With more experience and with a stronger coach, this group could turn out to be quite good. It will definitely not be very good or elite. 


Overall Offensive Grade: A- Good - So much depends upon the offensive line. They were below average last year, and Bryce managed to win the Heisman. If they can be basically good — not very good or great — then the offense could be very good and even even explosive. (It has looked explosive in the fall scrimmages.) Gibbs and the receivers will be fun to watch. 



The Defense


This should be a really good defensive group for Alabama. 


Defensive Line

There are no apparent stars in this group, but plenty of solid, experience players. Byron Young could have a breakout year like Phil Mathis did in 2021. Tim Smith has always been said to have a lot of talent and has worked his way into a starting position. Justin Eboigbe apparently does a good job in a quiet fashion. (I can’t say I remember him making a play during his career.) Jaheim Oatis has been the legend of camp at 360. The dude is an immovable object. He’s not much in pass rushing but he’s quite the run stuffer. Keep an eye on Jamil Burroughs who has had good moments and can flash as a pass rusher. 


Grade: A - Very Good - There is no obvious star in this group and no elite interior pass rusher. Still, there are several players with the upside to be stars (Smith, Oatis, Burroughs) and plenty of very experienced, solid guys that make running on the Tide very difficult. 


Linebacker

This is one of the best linebacking groups in Alabama history. On the Edge, Will Anderson is likely the best player in college football and perhaps the best defensive player of the Saban era. This is not a bologna internet rumor; they legitimately limited his reps in the spring because he was so disruptive that the offense struggled to get much done in practice. (Alabama had to do this with Cornelius Bennett in the 80’s.) Dallas Turner had 8.5 sacks as a true freshman on the other side of Anderson. He won just about every freshman All-American honor that one can. Former five-star Chris Braswell had an excellent spring; he’s a pure pass rusher. (In dime, Alabama will have Turner and Braswell on the edges and Anderson next to Byron Young at interior line.) 


In the middle, Henry To’o To’o is preseason All-SEC. He’s started three seasons in the SEC and recorded 111 tackles and 4 sacks last year. Jaylen Moody is a personal favorite of mine; all he does is make plays when he’s in the game. As a redshirt season, he’s waited his turn and is a very good linebacker (although he has a reputation for busting assignments at times). Deontae Lawson continues to impress inside and will be a star when his time comes. (I think Moody will hold him off during this year.) 


Grade: A+ - Great - This is an all-time great group. Enjoy it. You don’t see position groups like this but once in a generation or so. 



Secondary

Several publications rate Alabama as the best secondary in the country for 2022. Jordan Battle and Brian Branch are both eventual 1-2 round picks in the draft. They are stars. Demarco Hellums has played lots of football for the Tide. Malachi Moore is a valuable reserve, having started plenty of football games. 


Corners have less experience but an insane amount of talent. Many people project Eli Ricks to be a first round draft pick, but he doesn’t seem to have shown up in Tuscaloosa. He’s had back trouble and has seemed to get the defense yet. Former five-star, Kool-Aid McKinstry is thought to be the next great one at Alabama. Terrion Arnold is a former five-star and a favorite of the coaches. These two may take some lumps but they should get better and better as the season progresses. Kyrie Jackson, our 6’3 corner, remains a little raw but is still a very valuable corner that could start if Arnold struggles. He will get plenty of action. 


Grade: A…Very Good - The corners lack experience but have a ton of talent. The back four are excellent. I think this should be a very good group for Alabama, who should benefit from the pass rush of the front four. 



Overall Defensive Grade: A….Very Good - The only thing that keeps this group from being great is the lack of a proven interior pass rusher from the DL. Still, this will probably be the best defense in the country in the coming year. It should be really fun to watch the edge pass rush. If someone emerges as a threatening interior pass rusher (Young, Smith, Burroughs), then this group could be memorable. 




The Schedule


The schedule is manageable but there are some very tricky road games for the Tide. Ill break the schedule into three parts. 


Manageable Beginning

Utah State

Don’t be fooled. This team won their conference last year and reached 11 wins. They’ve lost quite a bit from that team. Alabama should win handily but don’t be stunned if Utah St. makes this competitive at points. Still….. WIN


Texas

Steve Sarkesian is the best overall offensive coordinator in the college game and the Longhorns have one of the best sets of skills positions players in the country. Expect them to score some points on Alabama’s defense. However, the Horns defense was utterly miserable last year and I think they expect it to be pretty bad again. The Alabama pass rush should keep Texas from scoring too many points, such that the game is in doubt in the fourth quarter. 


La-Monroe

Revenge game for Nick Saban from 2007. Big win for the Tide. 


Vanderbilt 

Vandy was impressive in their 60+ point showing v. Hawaii, but this list still Vanderbilt. WIN


Record: 4-0


The Challenging Road Games


Arkansas

I think Arkansas will be a very good team, one of the best in the SEC. This game at Arkansa is utterly dangerous. Alabama could get caught looking ahead to Texas AM. ARK will return a very nice roster and a solid QB. They’ve got a very good coaching staff. If Alabama does not play a good game, they could be in trouble in this underrated venue. 


Tennessee

Some believe this is the most dangerous game of the year. UT will put up serious points on anyone. The Big Orange fanbase is desperate for relevance again. (They haven’t beaten a top 10 opponent since 2006.) Alabama has beaten them 15 years in a row. They’ve got a very dangerous QB, some good receivers, and a tricky offense to defend. Can Alabama contain Hooker and friend. 


Ole Miss
I don’t think this is a particularly good Ole Miss team as they rebuild from last year, but Lane Kiffin is always scary. I think this is the least concerning of the road tests. 


LSU

Brian Kelly has inherited a sub-par LSU roster and the QB situation isn’t very good, but this guy can flat out coach. Playing in Death Valley is always a challenge. I think Alabama should handle this game but beware of the Fighting Bayou Bengals. 


Record: 4-0 If there is going to be a regular season loss, I think it falls in this stretch, most likely at Arkansas or Tennessee. Those are two really hard games in adverse circumstances. Keep in mind that Bama’s OL struggled mightily last year in loud contexts. 


Home Stretch


Texas A&M

This is being billed as the game of the century. Should be fun. I’m sorry, until Jimbo Fisher reveals something other than the fact that he’s an 8-4 coach, I’ll continue to believe he’s an 8-4 coach. TAM bought a nice roster last year, but that will not be as relevant in 2022. They lost six of the starts in their front seven. That will be a massive problem in this game. Haynes King could be a star at QB, but Max Johnson is challenging him, and that guy has proven to be as average as unsalted grits during his career at LSU.  I think Alabama wins this game at home.  WIN


Mississippi State

The Bulldogs return 14 starters from a pretty solid team. They are going to win 8-9 games in my opinion and be around the top 3 teams in the West. They just don’t match up well with Alabama at all, as evidenced by the last two blow out losses to the Tide, where Alabama won 49-9 and 41-0. Average margin of defeat: 40.5 Miss St will be a good team but they aren’t beating Alabama in Tuscaloosa.  WIN


Auburn

Auburn thrives when expectations are low. They are being picked to finish dead last in the West. Usually means that they win the national title, right? Wrong. The offensive line is really bad, they have no significant threats at receiver, and the QB situations seems dire. I think Harsin is quite good at coaching football (real bad at recruiting and leadership). Don’t forget that Auburn shouldn’t have lost three of the late season games (Miss St., USCe, Bama) but shot themselves in the foot and gave away major advantages. Auburn should have a pretty good defense and they have one of the best 1-2 punches at RB. Still, I think Auburn gets drilled in this game. The average margin of victory in the last five Iron Bowls in Bryant Denny has been 28. It seems that all of the forces around Bryan Harsin are cheering for his failure; I’d be surprised if Harsin is coaching this game.  WIN


Austin Peay - Fun game to take the kids to with nice weather and no need to watch the game. 


Record: 4-0



Worst Case Scenario
If Bryce Young gets injured, expectations on the season decline dramatically. (Generally for any team if you lose your starting QB, you’re toast, minus Alabama in 2018 with Jaylen and Tua or 2019 with Too and Mac.) 


Also, if Alabama loses both offensive tackles, they become very vulnerable. Kite and George are both massive drop offs from the starters on the offensive line. We could get by and possibly win the national title if only one of Steen and Latham goes down, but both would be a death nail. 


In either circumstance, I think Alabama would still win the West and maybe make the playoff, but the national title would be off the table. 


What’s I Think Will Happen

For me the question on the regular season is whether Alabama goes 11-1 or 12-1, either of which has been their record in 12 out of the last 14 years. There is a stretch where there could be a loss. Alabama goes to Arkansas, has a major hype game v. TAM at home, and then has to go play a dangerous Tennessee team in Knoxville. Can Alabama go 3-0 in that stretch? Yes, I think so. 


When you think about playing this Alabama team, you have the miserable challenge of facing a defense with two eventual top 10 picks at the edge. I say it again, Dallas Turner and Will Anderson combined for 27 sacks last year! They have four multi-year starters in the back secondary. The D-Line and interior linebackers are filthy against the run. It’s going to be very hard to score points, and it’s going to be highly probable that a QB will throw lots of interceptions. 


Meanwhile, on the other side of the ball, Alabama returns the Heisman trophy winner, they have three returning starters on the interior line,  and likely have a first round draft pick at running back. They are loaded. Particularly because of Bryce Young, they have the ability to outscore teams but probably won’t need to. 


There are a number of little factors at play as well, such as:

(1) First time in a long time that both coordinators are not new. 


(2) The attitude and leadership of the team are very good. You can hear it in Saban’s press conferences; he talks about it often. (Saban apparently told the team after the second scrimmage that they had the opportunity to be a “special team” if they maintained the hard work and good attitude.)


(3) A really good kicker and a reliable punter. 


(4) An unusual amount of experience. The Tide usually has so many players leave early that it’s hard to build up lots of experience. Eight returning starters in defense is unheard of. Four on offense isn’t too bad. 


(5) Success in the transfer portal. Gibbs, Steen, and Burton will be significant assets for the offense in filling in gaps and adding more explosion. 


(6) Rare occasion where it seems like both the offense and defense could be great. 


I don't mean to be a Bammer. In my years of doing this, only once have I picked an Alabama team to go undefeated and that was 2011. But the scrimmage that I saw was unlike any Bama team I've seen before. Injuries happen, bad breaks occur, but what I saw blew me away. I've heard Saban's internal view of this team and it's eye-opening. 


In the end, I’m going bold. I like this team to go 15-0 and to be one of the all-time great Saban teams. In my eyes, Alabama could lose a game in that 3-game murderers row or in the SEC title (I highly doubt that). Regardless, I like the 2022 Crimson Tide team to win the seventh national title of the Saban era.

No comments:

Post a Comment